Carrying Blanks in your EDC...Ingenious or Idiotic?

Published on November 16, 2019
Duration: 5:49

This video explores the controversial practice of carrying a blank round as the first round in an EDC firearm magazine. The presenter discusses the potential benefits, such as avoiding the need to rack the slide in a high-stress situation and mitigating negligent discharge risks, alongside significant drawbacks, including the blank's ineffectiveness in a lethal force encounter and the potential for complacency. The core debate centers on whether the perceived safety benefits outweigh the critical failure of the first round to be effective.

Quick Summary

Carrying a blank as the first round in an EDC firearm is debated for its safety and tactical implications. Proponents suggest it avoids racking the slide and reduces negligent discharge risk, while critics highlight its ineffectiveness in stopping a threat and potential for close-range injury.

Chapters

  1. 00:10Introduction: Educating the Viewer
  2. 00:32Viewer Email: The Blank Round Concept
  3. 00:54Context: Avoiding Chambered Rounds
  4. 01:06The Problem: Racking the Slide
  5. 01:21The Solution: Blank as First Round
  6. 01:30Reasoning: Missing the First Shot Myth
  7. 02:03Deterrent Effect of Firing
  8. 02:15Blank Cycles the Slide
  9. 02:36Negative: First Round Ineffectiveness
  10. 02:50Blank Round Danger at Close Range
  11. 03:03Personal Anecdote: Blank Round Injury
  12. 03:33Likelihood of Scenario vs. Negligent Discharge
  13. 03:44Positive: No Need to Rack Slide
  14. 04:13Psychological Deterrent of Noise
  15. 04:21Summary: Pros and Cons
  16. 04:43Potential for Complacency
  17. 04:50Viewer Opinion: Revolutionary or Dumb?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the primary argument for carrying a blank round as the first round in an EDC firearm?

The main reason is to avoid the need to rack the slide in a high-stress self-defense situation. This practice aims to maintain a chambered round without a live cartridge initially, potentially reducing the risk of negligent discharge until the blank is fired.

What are the significant drawbacks of using a blank as the first round in an EDC magazine?

The most critical drawback is that a blank round is ineffective for self-defense. It cannot stop a threat, and relying on it could be fatal. Additionally, while not deadly at range, blanks can still cause injury at very close proximity due to muzzle blast.

Can a blank round cause injury, and if so, how?

Yes, blank rounds can cause injury at very close range. The damage is not from the wad but from the gas and energy expelled from the muzzle. This can result in severe bruising or other injuries, as demonstrated by an anecdote of a blank fired into a chest.

Does carrying a blank first round eliminate the risk of negligent discharge?

No, it does not entirely eliminate the risk. While it reduces the chance of having a live round chambered initially, accidental discharge of the blank itself could still cause injury if the firearm is mishandled or pointed at someone's face at close range.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →