New Hotness: Closed-Emitter Pistol Optics — GMP#245

Published on August 9, 2024
Duration: 32:56

This discussion between Guns Magazine editor Brent Wheat and American Cop.com editor Eric Ghouse delves into the comparison between closed-emitter and open-emitter pistol red dot optics. Ghouse, an instructor at Gunsite Academy, emphasizes the durability and environmental resistance of closed-emitter designs, particularly for duty or harsh conditions, while acknowledging the wider field of view offered by some open-emitter models. The conversation also covers mounting systems, the importance of backup irons, and the evolving landscape of optic technology.

Quick Summary

Closed-emitter pistol red dot optics offer superior durability and protection against environmental factors like dirt and moisture, making them ideal for duty or harsh conditions. While open-emitter designs may provide a wider field of view, they are more susceptible to obstruction. Experts emphasize that the optic's mounting system is often the weakest point, and backup iron sights are crucial for reliability.

Chapters

  1. 00:04Introduction: Open vs. Closed Emitter Red Dots
  2. 01:10Sponsor: Right On Optics
  3. 01:46Guest Introduction: Eric Ghouse
  4. 04:09Defining Open vs. Closed Emitter Optics
  5. 05:34Durability Concerns: Open Emitter Obstruction
  6. 06:15Optics for Long Guns vs. Handguns
  7. 07:37How Open Emitter Optics Work
  8. 09:11Closed Emitter Optics: Aimpoint Acro P2 Example
  9. 09:48Drawbacks of Closed Emitter Optics: Printing
  10. 10:11Field of View Differences
  11. 10:36Hybrid Enclosed Emitter Designs
  12. 11:12The Weak Point: Optic Mounts
  13. 11:36Evolution of Optic Mounting: Direct Mill to Plates
  14. 12:45Factory Slide Cuts for Optics
  15. 13:50Trend Towards Closed Emitter Pistol Optics
  16. 14:25New Closed Emitter Optic Releases
  17. 15:14Battery Placement Innovations
  18. 15:51Operator Mechanics: Open vs. Closed
  19. 16:54Field of View and Target Acquisition
  20. 17:24Trijicon SRO: Large Window Example
  21. 18:38Using Large Optics on Shotguns and Competition Handguns
  22. 19:02Narrow Field of View: Delta Point Micro
  23. 20:07Maintenance: Cleaning Emitters
  24. 20:29Optic Durability Issues: Trijicon RMR Anodizing
  25. 21:07Red Dot Optic Robustness
  26. 21:39Planning for Optic Failure
  27. 22:07Training for Broken/Blocked Optics
  28. 22:36Using Optic Housing as a Sight
  29. 23:45Alternative Sighting Methods Without Dot
  30. 24:30Real-World Scenarios and Optic Reliability
  31. 25:08Personal Experience: Transitioning to Red Dots
  32. 25:21Vision Changes and Red Dot Benefits
  33. 26:00Long-Range Accuracy with Red Dots
  34. 26:43Key Takeaway: Use an Optic and Optimize
  35. 27:36Choosing an Optic: Don't Get Bogged Down
  36. 28:03Proficiency Comes from Practice, Not Gear
  37. 29:11Closing Thoughts & Viewer Comments
  38. 31:22Housekeeping & Sponsor Mentions
  39. 32:32Final Sign-off

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main advantage of a closed-emitter pistol red dot optic?

The primary advantage of a closed-emitter red dot optic is its enhanced durability and protection against environmental factors like dirt, debris, and moisture. This makes them more reliable for duty use or in harsh conditions where an open emitter could become obstructed.

Are open-emitter red dot sights still viable for pistol use?

Yes, open-emitter red dot sights can still be viable, especially for competition or situations where extreme environmental exposure is less likely. However, users must be diligent about keeping the emitter and lens clean to ensure proper function.

What is the most common failure point for pistol red dot optics?

According to experts, the mounting system is often the weakest link in a pistol-red dot setup, rather than the optic itself. Proper installation and a robust mount are crucial for long-term reliability.

Should I use backup iron sights with a red dot optic on my pistol?

It is highly recommended to use backup iron sights with a red dot optic. They provide a critical secondary aiming system in case the red dot fails due to battery issues, damage, or obstruction, ensuring you can still engage targets.

What is the trend in pistol red dot optic design?

The current trend in pistol red dot optics is a significant shift towards closed-emitter designs. Manufacturers are increasingly offering these more robust options due to their superior protection against environmental elements, making them favored for duty and concealed carry.

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from GUNS and American Handgunner Magazines

View all →