Speedloader Challenge: HKS vs. Safariland

Published on March 12, 2016
Duration: 6:50

This guide details a speedloader reloading technique demonstrated by TheYankeeMarshal, comparing HKS and Safariland models. It covers the distinct mechanisms of each speedloader and their application with a Chiappa Rhino 200DS revolver. The expert emphasizes the practical advantages of the push-to-release system for defensive scenarios.

Quick Summary

The Safariland speedloader is recommended for defensive use over the HKS model due to its faster, push-to-release mechanism. Unlike the HKS's twist-knob, the Safariland doesn't require holding the cylinder stationary, making reloads quicker and more intuitive under pressure.

Chapters

  1. 00:24HKS Speedloader Intro
  2. 01:10Safariland Speedloader Intro
  3. 02:39Reloading Demonstration
  4. 05:07Ergonomic Comparison & Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between HKS and Safariland speedloaders?

The HKS speedloader uses a twist-knob mechanism to release rounds, requiring the user to hold the cylinder steady. The Safariland speedloader features a push-to-release system that is faster and more intuitive, not requiring cylinder stabilization.

Which speedloader is better for defensive use?

For defensive use, the Safariland speedloader is generally considered superior due to its faster, push-to-release mechanism that simplifies the reloading process under pressure. The HKS, while functional, requires more deliberate manipulation.

What firearm was used in the speedloader comparison?

The firearm used for the live reloading demonstration was a Chiappa Rhino 200DS revolver, chambered in calibers like .357 Magnum and .38 Special.

How do the release mechanisms of these speedloaders work?

The HKS speedloader requires twisting a knob to release the cartridges. The Safariland speedloader is activated by pushing down on its central post, which then ejects the rounds into the cylinder.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →