UpLula vs. Butler Creek Magazine Speed Loaders. Which is Best?

Published on May 19, 2019
Duration: 10:25

This video provides a practical comparison between the Maglula UpLula and Butler Creek ASAP pistol magazine speed loaders. Through direct testing, the UpLula demonstrated superior speed and reliability, loading a 33-round Glock magazine significantly faster than the Butler Creek ASAP. The UpLula also proved more versatile, functioning adequately with single-stack magazines where the ASAP failed. The host, drawing on 15 years of experience including competitive use, recommends the UpLula for its proven performance and ergonomics.

Quick Summary

The Maglula UpLula is the superior pistol magazine speed loader, loading a 33-round Glock magazine in 53 seconds compared to the Butler Creek ASAP's 1 minute 28 seconds. The UpLula also reliably functions with single-stack magazines, a task the ASAP failed at. With 15 years of experience, including competitive use, the UpLula is recommended for its speed, reliability, and ergonomics.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: UpLula vs Butler Creek ASAP
  2. 01:24Baseline Hand Loading Test
  3. 02:11Speed Loader Head-to-Head Race
  4. 03:45Performance Analysis: Speed & Reliability
  5. 05:29Market & Price Comparison
  6. 08:33Single-Stack Magazine Compatibility Test

Frequently Asked Questions

Which pistol magazine speed loader is faster, the UpLula or the Butler Creek ASAP?

In testing, the Maglula UpLula loaded a 33-round Glock magazine in 53 seconds, significantly faster than the Butler Creek ASAP, which took 1 minute and 28 seconds. This indicates the UpLula is approximately 40% faster for this task.

Does the Maglula UpLula work with single-stack magazines?

Yes, the Maglula UpLula works adequately with single-stack magazines. This is a key advantage over the Butler Creek ASAP, which failed to function with single-stack magazines during testing because the follower dug into the plastic.

What are the key differences between the Maglula UpLula and Butler Creek ASAP?

The Maglula UpLula is faster, more reliable (especially with single-stack mags), has higher user ratings, and is slightly cheaper. The Butler Creek ASAP is slower and has compatibility issues with single-stack magazines.

Is the Maglula UpLula recommended for competitive shooting?

Yes, the host, with 15 years of experience including 3-gun competitions, specifically recommends the Maglula UpLula due to its long-term reliability and ergonomic design, making it suitable for high-volume shooting scenarios.

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from DEUCE AND GUNS

View all →