Urban Tactical Knife Comparison BK-3, Ontario SP-8, Ontario QAB & Camillus Carnivore

Published on December 16, 2019
Duration: 25:05

This video compares four tactical knives designed for urban survival and utility: the Becker BK3, Ontario SP-8, Ontario QAB, and Camillus Carnivore. The reviewer assesses their performance as pry bars, choppers, machetes, and general field tools, highlighting the BK3 as a strong contender for urban survival due to its balance of features and portability, while noting the SP-8's heft and the Carnivore's effectiveness as a machete. The QAB is identified as primarily a dedicated pry bar.

Quick Summary

Tactical urban knives are versatile tools designed for prying, chopping, and forced entry. They are useful for accessing locked areas, breaking down barriers, and performing heavy-duty tasks in survival or emergency situations, making them excellent additions to go-bags. The Ontario QAB is specifically designed as a 'Quick Access Pry Bar' and lacks a sharpened edge.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to Tactical Knives
  2. 00:19Comparing Four Tactical Knives
  3. 01:17The Appeal of Tactical Urban Knives
  4. 02:02Ontario QAB: Quick Access Pry Bar
  5. 02:54Becker BK3: K-Bar Collaboration
  6. 04:04Ontario SP-8: Survival Machete
  7. 05:27Camillus Carnivore: Titanium Bonded Blade
  8. 06:59Cardboard Cutting Test
  9. 08:21Feathering Test
  10. 10:06Pry Bar Test
  11. 11:29Saw Blade Test
  12. 12:27Limb Cutting Test
  13. 12:50Batoning Test
  14. 14:08Kindling and Sapling Cutting
  15. 16:12Tree Chopping Test
  16. 16:49Trenching/Digging Test
  17. 18:01Concrete Impact Test
  18. 18:50Paracord Cutting Test
  19. 19:15Strength and Flex Test
  20. 20:11Post-Use Condition Assessment
  21. 21:13Key Takeaways and Recommendations
  22. 23:34Self-Defense Considerations
  23. 24:01Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main uses for tactical urban knives like the Becker BK3 or Ontario SP-8?

Tactical urban knives are versatile tools designed for prying, chopping, and forced entry. They are useful for accessing locked areas, breaking down barriers, and performing heavy-duty tasks in survival or emergency situations, making them excellent additions to go-bags.

How does the Ontario QAB differ from other tactical knives in this comparison?

The Ontario QAB is specifically designed as a 'Quick Access Pry Bar' and lacks a sharpened edge. Its primary function is prying and leverage, distinguishing it from knives like the Becker BK3 or Ontario SP-8, which are also designed for cutting and chopping.

Which knife is best suited for machete-like tasks such as cutting brush?

The Camillus Carnivore excels as a machete for cutting brush and limbs due to its long blade and titanium-bonded construction. While the Ontario SP-8 can also chop, its heavier weight makes it less ideal for prolonged brush clearing compared to the Carnivore.

Is the Becker BK3 a good all-around urban survival tool?

Yes, the Becker BK3 is considered a strong contender for urban survival. It balances chopping, prying, and portability well, featuring a robust build and a practical Kydex sheath, making it a versatile tool for various emergency scenarios.

More from SensiblePrepper

View all →