NRA Gun Gear of the Week: Shield v. Shield—Conclusion

Published on August 18, 2017
Duration: 4:17

This video concludes a "Shield vs. Shield" project comparing a modified Smith & Wesson M&P Shield 9 against a Performance Center model. The project gun, upgraded with Trijicon sights, an Apex trigger, and Talon grips, was tested against the stock Performance Center Shield in a 50-round course of fire. While the project gun offered faster first-shot acquisition due to its sights, the Performance Center model yielded slightly tighter groups. Both demonstrated excellent trigger performance and recoil management, with Talon grips providing a significant grip enhancement for their cost.

Quick Summary

The "Shield vs. Shield" project aimed to enhance a base Smith & Wesson M&P Shield 9 to match or surpass a Performance Center model. Upgrades included Trijicon sights, an Apex trigger, and Talon grips. While the modified Shield offered faster initial shots, the Performance Center model yielded tighter groups. Both performed flawlessly, with Talon grips noted for exceptional value.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Shield vs. Shield Project Conclusion
  2. 00:15Project Goal: Base Shield vs. Performance Center
  3. 00:27Project Gun Upgrades
  4. 00:4350-Round Course of Fire
  5. 01:00Speed vs. Accuracy Results
  6. 01:07Impact of Sights on Speed
  7. 01:40Trigger Performance Comparison
  8. 02:10Recoil Management and Grip
  9. 02:37Final Evaluation and Reliability
  10. 03:09Price Comparison: MSRPs and Upgrades
  11. 03:45Best Value Component: Talon Grips
  12. 04:00Project Wrap-up and Future Content

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the goal of the "Shield vs. Shield" project?

The goal was to take a base model Smith & Wesson M&P Shield 9 and upgrade its performance with aftermarket parts to meet or exceed the performance of a factory Performance Center Shield.

How did the modified Shield and the Performance Center Shield compare in shooting drills?

The modified Shield was slightly faster, particularly in first-shot acquisition, while the Performance Center Shield produced slightly tighter groups and had one less missed shot.

What aftermarket parts were used to upgrade the base Shield?

The base Shield was upgraded with Trijicon HD night sights, an Apex Tactical Specialties Action Enhancement Trigger and Duty Carry Kit, and Talon Grips for improved performance.

Which component provided the best value for the money in the Shield upgrade project?

Talon Grips, costing under $20, were identified as providing the best bang for the buck, offering the most significant performance increase relative to their price.

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from NRApubs

View all →