Freezing Rifle Test. (AK, AR-15, SCAR, FAL etc)

Published on January 2, 2022
Duration: 37:08

This comprehensive test evaluates the reliability of various rifle platforms, including AK, AR-15, SCAR, and AUG, under extreme cold and ice conditions. Well-worn rifles were used to simulate real-world professional use. The AK platforms and Steyr AUG demonstrated superior performance, consistently cycling despite significant ice accumulation, while AR-15s and other designs struggled with frozen components.

Quick Summary

AK platforms and the Steyr AUG proved most reliable in Garand Thumb's extreme cold and ice rifle test. These designs showed superior mechanical leverage to overcome ice, making them better suited for sub-arctic environments compared to AR-15s, which struggled with frozen safeties and triggers.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to the Freezing Test
  2. 03:00Ammunition and Magazine Baseline
  3. 04:30Baseline Function Testing
  4. 10:01Phase 1: Freezing Rain Simulation
  5. 11:08Phase 1 Results
  6. 15:05Phase 2: Full Immersion Freezing
  7. 18:47Phase 2 Results and Final Assessment

Frequently Asked Questions

Which rifle platforms are most reliable in extreme cold and ice?

According to Garand Thumb's test, AK platforms (like the AKM and AK-105) and the Steyr AUG demonstrated the highest reliability in extreme cold and ice conditions, consistently cycling despite significant ice buildup.

What are the main failure points for AR-15s in freezing temperatures?

AR-15 platforms in the test struggled with frozen safeties and magazine releases. Some experienced 'dead triggers' due to internal ice affecting the firing pin or trigger mechanism, requiring more effort to clear.

How did the SCAR-H perform in the freezing rifle test?

The FN SCAR-H encountered an extraction failure during the freezing rain simulation phase of the test, indicating a potential vulnerability to ice accumulation affecting its cycling.

What was the methodology for Garand Thumb's freezing rifle test?

The test used well-worn rifles (5,000-15,000 rounds) and subjected them to simulated freezing rain and full water immersion, then tested their function in sub-freezing temperatures to assess reliability.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Garand Thumb

View all →