A Sit Down with John Petrolino

Published on January 24, 2025
Duration: 23:21

This video discusses the alleged racial bias in New Jersey's firearm permit application process, particularly concerning permits to carry. Journalist John Petrolino highlights how the state's 'temperament' clause, a subjective standard, disproportionately denies permits to Black citizens. He details his efforts to obtain data and official comment, revealing a lack of guidance from the Attorney General's office on addressing this bias. The discussion also touches on the implementation of subjective criteria post-Bruen and the challenges faced by applicants.

Quick Summary

New Jersey's permit to carry system faces scrutiny for alleged racial bias, with data showing Black citizens are denied at more than double the rate of white citizens. Over 50% of denials stem from subjective 'temperament' standards, a criterion applied disproportionately to minority applicants.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction with John Petrolino
  2. 01:36Bold Statement: Gun Control and Racism
  3. 02:00Permit to Carry in New Jersey
  4. 02:13Attorney General's Data Order
  5. 02:53Subjective Standard: 'Temperament'
  6. 03:31Denial Rates Under Subjective Standard
  7. 04:05Bruen Response Law and Subjectivity
  8. 05:32Second Layer: Racial Data Analysis
  9. 05:53OPRA Request for Race Data
  10. 06:32Racial Disparities in Permit Denials
  11. 07:04Subjective Criteria and Racial Bias
  12. 07:34Seeking Comment from Attorney General
  13. 08:46Zero Guidance on Racial Bias Issues
  14. 09:55AG Declines Comment on Lack of Guidance
  15. 10:16Parallels: Medical Field vs. Firearm Permits
  16. 11:02AG's Response to John Petrolino
  17. 11:44Governor Murphy's Office Response
  18. 12:06African-American Centric Groups
  19. 13:21Statisticians Analyze Permit Data
  20. 14:02Case Study: Leonard's Permit Denial
  21. 15:17Issuing Authorities Abusing Citizens
  22. 17:35News 2A's Infringement Report
  23. 18:18Permit Application Timelines
  24. 18:43Success with Infringement Report
  25. 19:31Lawsuit Considerations
  26. 20:09Working for News 2A
  27. 20:30How to Follow John Petrolino
  28. 21:01Recap: Gun Control, Racism, and NJ
  29. 21:16How to Follow John Petrolino (Final)
  30. 21:57Self-Defense Protection in 2024

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the 'temperament' standard in New Jersey firearm permits?

The 'temperament' standard in New Jersey refers to a subjective criterion used by issuing authorities to deny permits to carry. It's part of the 'interest of public health, safety, and welfare' clause and allows for denials based on an applicant's perceived disposition, rather than objective disqualifiers.

How does New Jersey's permit system allegedly show racial bias?

Data suggests Black citizens in New Jersey are denied permits to carry at more than double the rate of white citizens. This disparity is particularly pronounced when considering the subjective 'temperament' standard, which is applied at two and a half times the rate for Black applicants.

What is the Bruen response law in New Jersey regarding firearm permits?

Following the Supreme Court's Bruen decision, New Jersey enacted a response law that, according to critics, re-introduced subjective standards like 'proper temperament' into firearm permitting statutes, potentially contradicting the objective requirements emphasized by the Supreme Court.

Has the New Jersey Attorney General provided guidance on racial bias in firearm permit applications?

According to journalist John Petrolino, the New Jersey Attorney General's office has stated there are zero records of issuing guidance specifically on dealing with racial bias in firearm permit applications or the subjective standards used in denials.

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Washington Gun Law

View all →