SHOCKING! ATF Publishes Chilling Warning Rule After Losing 2A Court Battles!

Published on September 2, 2023
Duration: 9:44

This video breaks down a new proposed ATF rule (2022 R-17) that aims to redefine what it means to be 'engaged in the business' of dealing firearms. The rule, stemming from the Bipartisan Safer Communities Act, focuses on a subjective standard of 'predominantly earn a profit' rather than a numerical threshold. This could significantly impact private party firearm sales nationwide, potentially requiring FFL licenses for transactions previously considered personal or casual.

Quick Summary

The ATF's proposed rule 2022 R-17 redefines 'engaged in the business' of dealing firearms, shifting from numerical thresholds to a subjective standard of 'predominantly earn a profit.' This could impact private party sales nationwide, potentially requiring FFL licenses even for single transactions if intent to profit is demonstrated.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to ATF Proposed Rule
  2. 00:13Call to Action: Like & Subscribe
  3. 00:19Sponsor: Blackout Coffee
  4. 00:36Rule Overview: 2022 R-17
  5. 01:05Definition of 'Engaged in Business'
  6. 01:25Incorporating 'Predominantly Earn a Profit'
  7. 02:00Key Clarifications in the Rule
  8. 02:33Presumed Conduct for Dealers
  9. 02:50Profit Intent Without Gain
  10. 03:1390-Day Commenting Period
  11. 03:30Alternative Considered: Numerical Threshold
  12. 04:07Subjective Standard Explained
  13. 04:45Court Precedents on Intent
  14. 05:33Presumption of Engagement
  15. 06:09Money-Based Standard
  16. 06:35Beyond Monetary Value
  17. 07:00Repetitive Sales & Timeframes
  18. 07:18New or Like-New Firearms
  19. 07:43Practical Impact on Viewers
  20. 08:26Criminal Penalties
  21. 08:40Nationwide Impact & Backdoor Checks
  22. 09:03Questions & Channel Support
  23. 09:32Outro

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the ATF's new proposed rule (2022 R-17) about?

The ATF's proposed rule 2022 R-17 aims to redefine what it means to be 'engaged in the business' of dealing firearms. It focuses on a subjective standard of 'predominantly earn a profit' rather than a specific number of transactions, potentially impacting private party firearm sales nationwide.

How does the new ATF rule change the definition of a firearms dealer?

Previously, there was a focus on numerical thresholds. This new rule emphasizes a subjective intent to 'predominantly earn a profit.' Even a single transaction, combined with evidence of intent to sell more, could classify someone as a dealer requiring an FFL.

Does the ATF rule require actual profit to be made to need an FFL?

No, the proposed rule clarifies that the intent to predominantly earn a profit does not require the person to have actually received pecuniary gain. The intent itself, along with other factors, can be sufficient to require an FFL license.

What is the timeframe for commenting on the new ATF proposed rule?

Once published, there will be a 90-day commenting period. Firearm advocates are encouraged to submit comments in opposition to the proposed rule during this window.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Armed Scholar

View all →