Ground Breaking Supreme Court Bump Stock Decision!!!

Published on November 25, 2021
Duration: 8:42

This video provides an expert-level analysis of the Supreme Court case Aposhian v. Garland concerning the ATF's reclassification of bump stocks as machine guns. The speaker, an attorney and 2A advocate, details the legal history, the ATF's rule change under the Trump administration, and the arguments presented by both the petitioners and the Biden administration regarding Chevron deference and the Rule of Lenity. The decision on whether the Supreme Court will hear the case is anticipated around December 10th.

Quick Summary

The Supreme Court is considering Aposhian v. Garland, a case challenging the ATF's reclassification of bump stocks as machine guns. The core legal debate centers on whether to apply Chevron deference, favoring the ATF's interpretation, or the Rule of Lenity, which interprets ambiguous criminal statutes in favor of the individual. A decision on whether the Court will hear the case is anticipated around December 10th.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Supreme Court Considers Bump Stock Case
  2. 00:16Channel Support: USCCA
  3. 00:27Channel Support: Firearms Policy Coalition
  4. 00:38Case Challenging ATF Interpretation
  5. 01:04ATF, NFA, and Bump Stocks
  6. 01:27Consequences of New ATF Bump Stock Rule
  7. 01:47Details of Aposhian v. Garland Case
  8. 02:05Biden Admin and ATF's Interpretation
  9. 02:34Petitioners Reply to Biden Administration
  10. 02:53Explanation of Chevron Deference
  11. 03:45Chevron vs Rule of Lenity
  12. 04:18US: Supreme Court Not Needed
  13. 04:33Petitioner: Supreme Court Needed
  14. 04:56Case Has Been Fully Briefed
  15. 05:25Supreme Court Decision Options
  16. 05:59Supreme Court Should Grant Review
  17. 07:13Supreme Court's Decision
  18. 07:22December 10th Decision

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main legal issue in the Aposhian v. Garland case?

The primary legal issue is whether the ATF's reclassification of bump stocks as machine guns is a valid interpretation of federal law, specifically the National Firearms Act and the Gun Control Act.

What is Chevron deference and how does it apply here?

Chevron deference is a legal principle where courts defer to an administrative agency's interpretation of an ambiguous statute. The Biden administration argues the ATF's bump stock rule is entitled to this deference.

What is the Rule of Lenity and why is it relevant?

The Rule of Lenity dictates that ambiguous criminal statutes must be interpreted in favor of the defendant. Petitioners argue this rule should apply to the bump stock definition, not Chevron deference.

When will the Supreme Court decide if they will hear the bump stock case?

The Supreme Court is expected to decide whether to grant review (certiorari) for the Aposhian v. Garland case around December 10th, with decisions typically announced the following week.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Armed Scholar

View all →