GunForHireRadio #378 - John Jillard On His Discriminatory Treatment

Published on August 28, 2018
Duration: 64:50

This video details the legal challenges faced by John Gilardi and Mark Cheeseman in their pursuit of a carry permit in New Jersey. It highlights the state's 'justifiable need' requirement for obtaining a permit, even for individuals with documented threats. The discussion covers the legal process, including court denials, appeals, and the role of advocacy groups like J-Factor. The segment emphasizes the difficulties law-abiding citizens face in exercising their Second Amendment rights in restrictive states.

Quick Summary

In New Jersey, obtaining a handgun carry permit requires proving a 'justifiable reason,' a significant hurdle even for those with documented threats. John Gilardi's case exemplifies this, as his application, motivated by threats from a former inmate, was denied, underscoring the state's stringent interpretation of self-defense needs.

Chapters

  1. 01:47Introduction & Guest Welcome
  2. 03:50Guest Introduction: John Gilardi
  3. 07:04The Cheeseman Gilardi Case & GoFundMe
  4. 07:35Military Veteran Status & NJ Laws
  5. 08:31The 'Justifiable Need' Requirement in NJ
  6. 09:07Personal Threat & Self-Defense Motivation
  7. 10:02Legal Process & Court Experience
  8. 11:19Prosecutor's Admission & Judge's Ruling
  9. 12:59Appeal Process & Legal Strategy
  10. 14:16Pro Se Filing & Brief Submission
  11. 14:31Rejection Due to Technicalities
  12. 15:45Case Acceptance & Calendar Status
  13. 20:19The Burden of Waiting for Approval
  14. 21:04Prosecutor's Arguments & Inmate's Status
  15. 23:23Interpreting Threats & Necessity
  16. 24:50Proximity to Workplace & Potential Encounters
  17. 25:33The Right to Self-Defense
  18. 26:17Next Steps & Federal Court Strategy
  19. 27:38Proving Urgent Necessity
  20. 28:01Restraining Orders as Justifiable Need
  21. 30:27Mental Toll of Constant Vigilance
  22. 31:00The Dilemma of Moving Out of State
  23. 31:30The Right to Protect Family
  24. 32:06Posthumous Permits in NJ
  25. 36:38Support the GoFundMe: Restore Carry to NJ
  26. 37:56Tragedy in Iowa & Illegal Immigration
  27. 41:06NJ Insurance & 'Murder Insurance' Debate
  28. 43:21NJ Governor on Arming Teachers
  29. 44:02Armed Security Guard Stops School Shooting
  30. 45:11Proposal for Armed Teachers in Schools
  31. 46:05Learning from Past Tragedies
  32. 47:56Call to Action: Calandra for NRA
  33. 49:10NJ SafeCon Event Information
  34. 49:51County Line Firearms Sponsorship
  35. 50:07Wills & Firearms Inheritance
  36. 52:30Self-Defense Incident: Glen Myers
  37. 53:31Home Security Measures
  38. 54:10Alarm Systems & Panic Buttons
  39. 55:18Alarm.com App Features
  40. 56:05Home Safety Drills & Code Words
  41. 57:54Child Abduction Prevention
  42. 58:49Door Security & Safe Rooms
  43. 59:59Cell Phone Emergency Protocols
  44. 61:18Outdoor Lighting & Defensive Landscaping
  45. 62:19Knife Rights Update & Upcoming Classes
  46. 62:43Massad Ayoob Event Announcement
  47. 63:00Support for Gilardi & Cheeseman Case
  48. 63:34Sharing the Message & Donations
  49. 64:04Closing Remarks & Show Outro

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main obstacle to obtaining a carry permit in New Jersey?

In New Jersey, the primary obstacle to obtaining a handgun carry permit is the requirement to demonstrate a 'justifiable reason' or 'good cause.' This means applicants must prove a specific, demonstrable need for self-defense beyond the general right to bear arms, which is a high bar to clear.

How did John Gilardi's personal threat factor into his carry permit application?

John Gilardi's application was motivated by threats from a former inmate. Despite this documented threat, his initial application was denied, highlighting the strict interpretation of 'justifiable need' in New Jersey, even when personal safety is demonstrably at risk.

What is the Cheeseman Gilardi case fighting for?

The Cheeseman Gilardi case, supported by J-Factor, is challenging New Jersey's restrictive right-to-carry laws. The legal battle aims to establish that documented threats and a clear need for self-defense should be sufficient grounds for a carry permit, pushing back against the 'justifiable need' requirement.

What role do technicalities play in New Jersey's carry permit applications?

Technicalities, such as font size in legal briefs, can lead to the rejection of carry permit applications in New Jersey. This highlights how procedural errors can derail substantive legal arguments, adding another layer of difficulty for applicants.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Gun For Hire Range

View all →