What do you think of this messed up law???

Published on December 12, 2017
Duration: 39:52

This video discusses Hawaii's law requiring medical marijuana users to surrender their firearms, deeming it unconstitutional. It explores the legal basis, including a 2016 Ninth Circuit ruling, and the potential implications for other states with legal marijuana. The discussion highlights the perceived inconsistency of allowing prescription painkillers while prohibiting firearm ownership for marijuana users.

Quick Summary

Hawaii's new law requires medical marijuana patients to surrender their firearms, a move critics deem unconstitutional. This policy, stemming from a 2016 Ninth Circuit ruling, forces legal marijuana users to forfeit their Second Amendment rights, sparking concerns about broader implications for states with legalized marijuana.

Chapters

  1. 01:54Introduction to Hawaii's Law
  2. 03:21Honolulu PD Letter Details
  3. 03:34Ninth Circuit Ruling Explained
  4. 04:07Inconsistency with Other Prescriptions
  5. 04:42Federal vs. State Marijuana Laws
  6. 06:22Legal to Drink and Carry?
  7. 08:53Federal vs. State Gun Purchase Laws
  8. 10:06Precedent for Other States
  9. 10:43National Carry Law Discussion
  10. 12:22HR 38 National Reciprocity Bill
  11. 14:37Carrying Rifles in Vehicles
  12. 15:36Empty Gun Jar Explanation
  13. 17:23Mall Parking Lot Shooting Incident
  14. 20:38State vs. Federal Purchasing Laws
  15. 22:03Alcohol vs. Marijuana Violence Statistics
  16. 29:04Plasma Rifles and Regulations
  17. 30:30"Desk Pop" Meaning
  18. 31:01Top 3 Guns of 2017 Discussion
  19. 33:21State Purchasing Law Differences
  20. 35:19Interstate Firearm Purchase Law
  21. 37:05Home Defense Firearm Debate
  22. 38:35Recommended Home Defense Handguns

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the new law in Hawaii regarding medical marijuana and gun ownership?

Hawaii is enforcing a law that requires individuals legally purchasing marijuana for medical purposes to surrender their firearms. This is reportedly based on a 2016 Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling and involves the Honolulu Police Department sending letters to patients demanding voluntary firearm surrender within 30 days.

Why is the Hawaii medical marijuana gun law considered unconstitutional?

The law is considered unconstitutional by critics because it forces legal medical marijuana users to forfeit their Second Amendment rights, while other prescription drugs, which may have more severe side effects or contribute to violence, are not subject to the same restrictions.

How does federal law affect marijuana users and gun ownership?

Federally, marijuana users are prohibited from purchasing firearms, as indicated by a question on the ATF Form 4473. This applies even in states where marijuana is legal, as federal law does not recognize state legalization for the purpose of firearm purchase.

Could Hawaii's law impact other states with legal marijuana?

Yes, the presenters express concern that Hawaii's law could set a precedent for other states that have legalized marijuana. They believe it could lead to similar firearm confiscation measures or stricter regulations in those states, despite differing legal frameworks.

What is the difference between carrying a firearm under the influence and being a legal marijuana user?

The core issue highlighted is that Hawaii is not just prohibiting carrying a firearm while under the influence of marijuana, but is actively confiscating firearms from individuals who are legally permitted to use medical marijuana. This is seen as a direct infringement on their right to bear arms.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Top Guns

View all →