What's Going On With the Lawsuit to Overturn Washington's Magazine Ban?

Published on August 3, 2022
Duration: 26:28

This video discusses the lawsuit Sullivan v. Ferguson, which challenges Washington State's ban on standard-capacity magazines (RCW 9.41.370, SB 5078). Lead counsel Joel Ard explains the case's current status, the impact of the Supreme Court's Bruin decision, and the related Duncan v. Bonta case. The discussion highlights how Bruin mandates a text, history, and tradition analysis for Second Amendment challenges, potentially invalidating magazine bans.

Quick Summary

The Sullivan v. Ferguson lawsuit challenges Washington State's ban on standard-capacity magazines (RCW 9.41.370). Following the Supreme Court's Bruin decision, which mandates a 'text, history, and tradition' analysis, and the GVR of Duncan v. Bonta, magazine bans are expected to be re-evaluated. Legal experts anticipate these bans may be found unconstitutional as standard-capacity magazines were historically in common use.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Sullivan v. Ferguson lawsuit about?

The Sullivan v. Ferguson lawsuit challenges Washington State's ban on standard-capacity magazines, codified as RCW 9.41.370 (Senate Bill 5078). The plaintiffs argue that this ban is unconstitutional under the Second Amendment.

How has the Supreme Court's Bruin decision affected magazine ban lawsuits?

The Bruin decision mandates that courts use a 'text, history, and tradition' analysis for Second Amendment challenges. This new standard requires a re-evaluation of laws like magazine bans, potentially invalidating them if they lack historical precedent.

What is the significance of the Duncan v. Bonta case being GVR'd?

The Supreme Court's Grant, Vacate, and Remand (GVR) of Duncan v. Bonta, which dealt with California's magazine ban, instructs the Ninth Circuit to re-analyze the ban using the Bruin standard. This action signals that the previous Ninth Circuit ruling was likely incorrect under the new constitutional framework.

What is the expected outcome for Washington's magazine ban after Bruin?

Given the Bruin decision's emphasis on text, history, and tradition, and the GVR of Duncan v. Bonta, legal experts anticipate that magazine bans like Washington's RCW 9.41.370 will likely be found unconstitutional. The analysis is expected to show that standard-capacity magazines were historically in common use and protected by the Second Amendment.

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Washington Gun Law

View all →