Is a Backup Gun Necessary for Self-Defense?

Published on June 11, 2025
Duration: 3:05

Former CIA officer Jason Hanson discusses the necessity and practicality of carrying a backup firearm. He explains the historical 'New York Reload' concept with revolvers and contrasts it with modern semi-automatic firearms that hold significantly more rounds. Hanson advises against ankle carry due to discomfort and suggests appendix or pocket carry as more viable options for a secondary firearm.

Quick Summary

Modern semi-automatic pistols with high magazine capacities (17+1 rounds) have reduced the necessity of backup guns compared to historical revolvers. While not always needed for everyday carry, a backup gun might be considered for remote locations. Ankle carry is generally uncomfortable, with appendix or pocket carry being more practical alternatives.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Backup Gun Necessity
  2. 00:15History of Backup Guns: The New York Reload
  3. 00:47Modern Firearms vs. Backup Guns
  4. 01:00When to Carry a Backup Gun
  5. 01:15Example: Sig Sauer P365 Pocket Carry
  6. 01:31Demonstration: Semi-Auto New York Reload
  7. 02:23Why Ankle Carry Sucks
  8. 02:42Alternative Backup Carry Methods
  9. 02:54Conclusion: Does a Backup Gun Make Sense?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the historical context of carrying a backup gun?

Historically, backup guns were common for law enforcement carrying revolvers with limited rounds. If their primary revolver ran dry, they would switch to a backup, a practice known as the 'New York Reload,' rather than reloading the first gun.

Are backup guns still necessary with modern firearms?

Modern semi-automatic pistols hold significantly more rounds (e.g., 17+1) than older revolvers. This increased capacity means backup guns are less essential for many civilians, though they may still be considered for specific situations like wilderness carry.

What are the downsides of ankle carry for a backup gun?

Ankle carry is generally considered uncomfortable and impractical. Even with a good holster, most people find it uncomfortable after about 30 minutes, making it difficult to access the firearm when needed.

What are recommended alternatives to ankle carry for a backup gun?

If you choose to carry a backup gun, more comfortable and accessible options include appendix carry or pocket carry. Some individuals opt for a combination, like a primary gun in the appendix position and a backup in their pocket.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from Jason Hanson

View all →