.40S&W is a DEAD Caliber (Says James Yeager)

Published on May 27, 2016
Duration: 7:12

The Yankee Marshal refutes James Yeager's claim that .40 S&W is a 'dead' caliber. He argues that caliber popularity fluctuates, with 9mm currently favored for cost and modern bullet tech. However, .40 S&W still excels in barrier penetration and isn't obsolete, despite the FBI's shift to 9mm for specific operational reasons. The speaker suggests .357 Magnum as a superior alternative.

Quick Summary

The Yankee Marshal argues .40 S&W is not dead, but experiencing a popularity cycle. While 9mm is favored for cost and modern bullets, .40 S&W excels in barrier penetration. The FBI's switch to 9mm was cost-driven, not an objective performance endorsement.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: James Yeager Declares .40 S&W Dead
  2. 01:54Caliber Popularity Cycles Explained
  3. 02:23Why the FBI Switched to 9mm
  4. 02:49.40 S&W vs. 9mm: Barrier Penetration
  5. 04:26Conclusion: Is .40 S&W Truly Dead?

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the .40 S&W caliber dead according to The Yankee Marshal?

No, The Yankee Marshal argues that .40 S&W is not dead, but rather not the current trend. He explains that caliber popularity ebbs and flows, and while 9mm is popular now, .40 S&W still offers advantages like superior barrier penetration.

Why did the FBI switch from .40 S&W to 9mm?

The FBI's transition to 9mm was primarily influenced by cost considerations and the high volume of fire their agents typically employ. This decision doesn't necessarily mean 9mm is objectively superior to .40 S&W in all performance aspects.

Does .40 S&W perform better than 9mm in certain situations?

Yes, the speaker highlights that .40 S&W often outperforms 9mm in penetrating hard barriers, particularly when using bonded ammunition. This makes it a relevant consideration for specific tactical applications.

What alternative caliber does The Yankee Marshal suggest?

While discussing the relevance of .40 S&W, The Yankee Marshal suggests that .357 Magnum is a superior alternative, implying it offers better performance characteristics for certain needs.

Related News

All News →

More General Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →