7 Of The Worst Cartridges For SHTF

Published on April 25, 2025
Duration: 11:41

This video identifies the worst calibers for SHTF scenarios, prioritizing mobility and ammunition availability. It criticizes common choices like 12 Gauge for bulk, niche AR rounds for scarcity, and powerful magnum calibers (.338 Lapua, .500 S&W, .50 AE, .50 BMG) for their extreme weight, recoil, noise, and limited supply. The core message is that practicality and widespread availability trump raw power or specialized ballistics in a survival situation.

Quick Summary

Powerful magnum calibers like .338 Lapua Magnum, .500 S&W Magnum, .50 AE, and .50 BMG are unsuitable for SHTF due to their massive recoil, deafening noise signatures that compromise stealth, and the sheer weight and bulk of both the ammunition and the firearms themselves.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: Why Some Calibers Fail SHTF
  2. 00:22#7: 12 Gauge Shotgun - Too Bulky
  3. 02:04#6: Niche AR Cartridges - Scarcity Issue
  4. 03:09#5: 5.45x39mm - Availability Decline
  5. 03:59#4: .338 Lapua Magnum - Impractical Power
  6. 05:17Honorable Mentions: 5.7x28 & .30 Carbine
  7. 06:56#3: .500 S&W Magnum - Overkill & Noise
  8. 08:25#2: .50 AE - Novelty & Cost
  9. 09:50#1: .50 BMG - The Ultimate SHTF Failure

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes 12 Gauge a poor choice for SHTF scenarios?

12 Gauge is criticized for SHTF due to its significant bulk and weight. Carrying a substantial amount of 12 gauge ammunition requires much more space and effort than carrying equivalent rounds of smaller pistol calibers like 9mm, hindering mobility.

Why are niche AR-15 cartridges like .338 ARC bad for SHTF?

Niche AR cartridges offer ballistic advantages but are poor SHTF choices because their ammunition is not widely produced or stockpiled. In a post-collapse scenario, finding resupply for these less common rounds would be nearly impossible compared to standard calibers.

Are powerful magnum calibers like .500 S&W suitable for SHTF?

No, powerful magnum calibers are generally unsuitable for SHTF. They suffer from massive recoil, deafening noise that compromises stealth, and the firearms and ammunition are extremely heavy and bulky, making them impractical for mobile survival.

What are the best calibers to consider for SHTF preparedness?

For SHTF, prioritize common, widely available calibers. Rounds like 9mm, 5.56 NATO, and 7.62x39mm are generally recommended due to their extensive production, stockpiling, and logistical ease compared to niche or magnum cartridges.

Related News

All News →

More General Videos You Might Like

More from Banana Ballistics

View all →