Smyth Busters: Is It Safe To Drop The Slide With a Round in the Chamber?

Published on February 23, 2021
Duration: 3:39

Dropping the slide on a chambered round can indeed break an extractor, especially on firearms with low-quality steel or improper extractor fitment. While modern external extractors on brands like Glock and Sig Sauer are generally more robust and easier to replace than traditional internal 'Browning' extractors found on 1911s, a properly beveled and tensioned extractor is crucial for all designs. Steel quality and proper polishing are key factors in preventing extractor failure.

Quick Summary

Dropping the slide on a chambered round can indeed break a pistol's extractor, especially if it's made of low-quality steel or improperly fitted. A proper bevel allows the extractor to slide over the rim, but poor design or materials increase the risk of failure.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: The Extractor Myth
  2. 00:30Internal vs. External Extractors
  3. 01:10Causes of Extractor Failure
  4. 02:00Steel Quality & Personal Anecdote
  5. 03:00Conclusion: Is It Safe?

Frequently Asked Questions

Can dropping the slide on a chambered round damage a pistol's extractor?

Yes, it can. While high-quality, properly tuned firearms are less likely to experience issues, a weak or poorly fitted extractor, especially one made from lower-quality steel or lacking a proper bevel, can break when the slide is dropped on a chambered round.

What's the difference between internal and external pistol extractors?

Internal extractors, like those on traditional 1911s, are housed within the slide. External extractors, common on Glocks, Sigs, and M&Ps, are mounted externally. External extractors are often easier to replace and less prone to tension issues.

What factors contribute to an extractor breaking?

Key factors include the quality of the steel used, the precision of the fit within the slide, and the presence of a sufficient bevel. A tight extractor or one that isn't polished correctly can snag on the rim of a chambered round, leading to breakage.

Related News

All News →

More Gunsmithing & DIY Videos You Might Like

More from Brownells, Inc.

View all →