2g-ACM - Rimless Enfields - M1917 vs Ishapore 2A1 - Dirty Berms

Published on October 17, 2017
Duration: 11:49

This InRangeTV episode details a 'rimless Enfield match' comparing a .308 Ishapore 2a and a .30-06 Model 1917 Enfield. The comparison highlights the reliability issues of original SMLEs and explores how conversions like the Ishapore 2a address these. The match stages test shooter skill and firearm performance, with a close finish emphasizing the interplay of sight quality and magazine capacity. Expert insights are provided on firearm design trade-offs and competitive shooting strategies.

Quick Summary

The 'rimless Enfield match' concept addresses SMLE reliability issues like rim lock and dirt-induced magazine failures. Competitors compare rifles like the .30-06 Model 1917 Enfield (6-round mag, superior sights) and the .308 Ishapore 2A1 (10-round mag, higher capacity), highlighting trade-offs between sight quality and ammunition capacity for competitive shooting.

Chapters

  1. 00:07Loading Mags for Rimless Enfield Match
  2. 00:18Introduction to InRange & Enfield Rifles
  3. 00:33SMLE Malfunctions in Matches
  4. 00:49Rimless Enfield Match Concept: M1917 vs Ishapore 2A
  5. 00:58Ishapore 2A .308 Details
  6. 01:17Rimless Cartridge Conversion History
  7. 01:44Model 1917 Enfield Introduction
  8. 02:15P17 Enfield History & Caliber
  9. 03:09P17 Enfield Specifications
  10. 03:20Match Comparison Setup: Ishapore vs P17
  11. 03:36Match Stages & Pistol Used
  12. 04:05Stage 1 Description & Execution
  13. 07:56Post-Stage 1 Debrief & Analysis
  14. 08:40Stage 1 Results & Close Finish
  15. 08:53Gear vs. Skill Performance Analysis
  16. 09:17Number 4 Enfield Potential
  17. 09:30Sight Picture Trade-offs
  18. 09:43Capacity Limitations & Solutions
  19. 09:59Preview of Next Stage: CQB

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a 'rimless Enfield match' and why was it conceived?

A 'rimless Enfield match' is a competition designed to address the historical reliability issues of original SMLE rifles, such as rim lock and magazine failures. It often involves modified or converted Enfields, like the Ishapore 2a, to ensure smoother operation and competitive viability.

How do the Model 1917 Enfield and Ishapore 2A1 compare in terms of specifications?

The Model 1917 Enfield is chambered in .30-06 Springfield with a 6-round magazine, while the Ishapore 2A1 is a .308 NATO conversion retaining the SMLE's 10-round magazine. The P17 is noted for its durable action and superior sights, whereas the Ishapore offers higher capacity.

What are the key performance differences observed between the M1917 Enfield and Ishapore 2A1 in competition?

In competition, the M1917 Enfield's superior iron sights can lead to better accuracy and fewer misses. However, the Ishapore 2A1's higher magazine capacity can reduce the frequency of reloads, offering a different strategic advantage. The final outcome often depends on the shooter's skill and the specific match stages.

What common malfunctions affect SMLE rifles in competitive shooting?

SMLE rifles can experience significant malfunctions in matches, primarily due to rim lock, where cartridge rims interfere with each other. Magazine failures caused by dirt ingress are also common, impacting feeding reliability and overall performance.

More Range & Competition Videos You Might Like

More from InRangeTV

View all →