1911 vs Beretta M9

Published on October 12, 2018
Duration: 10:09

Honest Outlaw provides an objective comparison between the 1911 platform and the Beretta M9, drawing on extensive experience with both. The review highlights key differences in action types (SA vs. DA/SA), capacity, safety mechanisms, price, and maintenance. For general self-defense, the M9 is recommended due to its capacity and value, while the 1911 remains favored for its superior trigger characteristics and accuracy potential.

Quick Summary

The Honest Outlaw recommends the Beretta M9 over the 1911 for general self-defense due to its higher capacity (17+1), lower cost (around $450), and simpler safety features. While the 1911 offers a superior single-action trigger, the M9's DA/SA action and capacity make it more practical for average users.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: 1911 vs Beretta M9
  2. 00:32Historical Context: Military Sidearms
  3. 01:07Specific Models: Dan Wesson Guardian 1911 & Beretta M9
  4. 01:35Caliber Debate: 9mm vs .45 ACP
  5. 02:341911 Trigger and Safeties
  6. 03:57Capacity and Weight Comparison
  7. 04:16Beretta M9 Action and Safety
  8. 06:18Price and Value Analysis
  9. 06:52Reliability and Maintenance
  10. 07:49Final Verdict and Recommendation

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the 1911 and the Beretta M9?

The 1911 typically features a single-action trigger and manual thumb/grip safeties, while the Beretta M9 is a DA/SA pistol with a slide-mounted safety. The M9 also boasts a higher capacity (17 rounds) compared to most 1911s (10 rounds in 9mm).

Which pistol is better for self-defense, the 1911 or the Beretta M9?

For the average user seeking a self-defense or home-defense tool, the Beretta M9 is recommended due to its higher capacity, lower cost, and straightforward safety features. The 1911 is preferred by those prioritizing trigger quality and absolute accuracy.

How do the prices of the 1911 and Beretta M9 compare?

The Beretta M9 offers significantly better value, with the reviewed model purchased for $450. Premium 1911 models, like the Dan Wesson Guardian, can cost around $1,300, making the M9 a more budget-friendly option.

What are the reliability considerations for the 1911 and Beretta M9?

Both platforms are reliable if properly maintained. The M9's military reliability issues are often attributed to poor maintenance or worn magazines. The 1911 generally requires more frequent cleaning and lubrication.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Honest Outlaw

View all →