357 Mag vs 44 Mag: Not Even Close In Lever Actions?

The Yankee Marshal is contemplating a firearm purchase using birthday gift certificates. He is torn between acquiring a Henry .357 Magnum lever-action rifle with a desirable case-hardened finish and an octagonal barrel, or waiting for a Chiappa Rhino in .44 Magnum. He also briefly considers a Colt Python but dismisses it for his personal use. The decision hinges on practicality versus the desire for a specific, currently unavailable model.

This video from TheGunCollective showcases a significant number of new firearm releases across various manufacturers. Key introductions include the Kel-Tec PR-3AT with its unique stripper clip system, the Rost Martin RM1F striker-fired pistol series, and Stoeger's additions to the STR line. Springfield Armory unveils the Echelon 4.0FC, while Smith & Wesson revives the Night Guard revolver series. The review also highlights collaborations like the Canik Prime Radian and the high-end Staccato C4X and Atlas Gunworks Project Alias. Other notable releases are the SDS Arms Inglis P-35 Hi-Power clones, PSA's modular AXR family, Zev Technologies' FDP-9 folding pistol, and Bond Arms' AR-compatible lever-action rifle.

This review showcases three Smith & Wesson revolvers suitable for home defense, highlighting their unique features and calibers. The Model 19-5 is a classic .357 Magnum, the Model 69 is a compact .44 Magnum Combat Magnum, and the Performance Center Model 327 TRR8 offers an 8-shot .357 Magnum with modern tactical features like accessory rails and Cerakote finish. The speaker demonstrates expertise in firearm features and comparisons.

This video demonstrates a ballistics test of the Smith & Wesson 629 Hunter Edition revolver chambered in .44 Magnum. Using DoubleTap 200 grain HP Lead-Free ammunition, the presenter measures muzzle velocity with a Garmin Xero C1 Pro chronograph. The results show impressive velocities, highlighting the power of this classic magnum cartridge in a modern platform.

This video compares the terminal ballistics of 10mm Auto and .357 Magnum by firing them into a frozen lake. The visual evidence suggests the .357 Magnum created a slightly larger and deeper impact crater in the ice, indicating potentially greater energy transfer in this specific test. The presenter, Mr. Madness, demonstrates a casual yet experimental approach to caliber comparison.

This review of the Henry Big Boy Carbine (H012GMCC) provides an expert-level overview of its features, including the color case hardened receiver, large loop lever, and octagonal barrel. The instructor emphasizes the critical role of cartridge overall length (OAL) in ensuring reliable feeding with lever-action firearms, particularly for .38 Special and .357 Magnum calibers. Plans for comprehensive ammunition testing in both the rifle and a revolver are detailed, aiming to identify optimal loads for performance and feeding.

This comparison tests the .50 AE Desert Eagle against the .44 Magnum in various barrier tests, including wood, steel, sand, and concrete. While both calibers showed impressive power, the .50 AE demonstrated superior performance in ballistic gel with deeper penetration and a larger wound channel. Ultimately, the video questions if the .50 AE's marginal gains justify its significantly higher cost per round compared to the versatile .44 Magnum.

This video provides a detailed comparison between .223 Remington and 5.56 NATO ammunition, demonstrating their performance differences through rigorous barrier testing. While visually identical, 5.56 NATO shows a slight advantage in velocity and energy. Crucially, 5.56 NATO exhibits superior barrier penetration against lumber and steel, whereas .223 Remington struggles. Specialized rounds like M855A1 also show enhanced performance against sand barriers.

This video tests the lethality of various 'less lethal' shotgun rounds, including rubber buckshot, bean bags, and specialized projectiles. The .410 rubber buckshot demonstrated significantly higher velocity and penetration than 12-gauge versions. Bean bag rounds proved to be the most damaging, causing substantial plywood destruction and ballistic gel displacement, leading the host to conclude they are the most lethal 'less lethal' option.

This video compares 9mm, .40 S&W, and .45 ACP through various barrier tests including lumber, sand, and concrete, alongside ballistics gel testing. While all calibers performed similarly through most barriers, the .40 S&W showed slightly better penetration and expansion in ballistics gel. The host ultimately favors 9mm due to its lower recoil and higher capacity, despite the .40 S&W's respectable performance.