$500 Black Aces S4 vs $2000 Benelli M4 | Is Cheaper "Just as Good"?

Published on May 27, 2023
Duration: 17:42

This video compares the Black Aces S4 ($500) and the Benelli M4 ($2000) shotguns, evaluating if the cheaper option is comparable. The review highlights their shared ARGO gas system, cycling capabilities with various ammunition, and similar operational feel. While the Benelli M4 is noted for its aesthetics and perceived higher quality, the Black Aces S4 is presented as a budget-friendly alternative that offers many of the same functional features. The video includes practical shooting drills and discusses recoil impulse, concluding that for casual use, the S4 is a viable option, though the M4 is favored for professional or high-round-count scenarios.

Quick Summary

The Black Aces S4 ($500) and Benelli M4 ($2000) shotguns both use the ARGO gas-operated system, ensuring reliable cycling of various ammunition. While the Benelli M4 excels in aesthetics and is recommended for high-volume professional use, the S4 offers comparable core functionality at a fraction of the cost, making it a viable budget option for casual shooters.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Initial Impressions
  2. 00:46Comparison Setup
  3. 01:37Black Aces S4 Overview
  4. 01:45Benelli M4 Overview
  5. 02:17ARGO System & Ammunition Compatibility
  6. 02:41Charging Handle & Parts Compatibility
  7. 02:56Magazine Capacity & Stock Differences
  8. 03:08Aesthetics & Design Comparison
  9. 03:29Feature Comparison: $500 vs $2000
  10. 03:53Recoil Impulse Discussion
  11. 04:21Shooting Test & Handling
  12. 05:03Operational Feel Comparison
  13. 05:15Detailed Feature Comparison
  14. 06:32Tournament Style Competition
  15. 06:50Mozambique Drill
  16. 09:02Build Drill Competition
  17. 09:55Build Drill with Benelli M4
  18. 11:02Cycling Birdshot Test
  19. 11:17Closing Thoughts & Value Proposition
  20. 13:13Range Noise Interruption
  21. 13:23Final Verdict & Recommendations
  22. 14:47Gear Quality & Self-Defense Philosophy
  23. 15:52Long-Term Reliability & Durability
  24. 16:11Stock Breakage Disclosure
  25. 16:34Call to Action & Channel Subscription
  26. 17:05Outro & Merch Promotion

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference in price between the Black Aces S4 and the Benelli M4 shotguns?

The Black Aces S4 shotgun is priced around $500, making it significantly more affordable than the Benelli M4, which typically costs about $2000. This price difference is a key factor in the comparison of their value and performance for different user needs.

Do both the Black Aces S4 and Benelli M4 shotguns use the same operating system?

Yes, both the Black Aces S4 and the Benelli M4 shotguns utilize the ARGO gas-operated system. This shared system allows both firearms to reliably cycle a wide variety of ammunition types, contributing to their similar operational feel and performance.

What are the key aesthetic and furniture differences between the Black Aces S4 and Benelli M4?

The Benelli M4 is often praised for its superior aesthetics, described as looking "10 times better" and "girthier." The Black Aces S4 offers optional wood furniture, while the Benelli M4 typically features black polymer furniture and does not come in a pistol grip version.

How does the Black Aces S4 compare to the Benelli M4 in terms of parts compatibility?

The charging handle on the Black Aces S4 is noted to be compatible with Benelli M4 parts. This means users could potentially swap or upgrade components between the two firearms, offering some level of parts interchangeability.

Which shotgun is recommended for high-volume shooting or professional use?

For users who plan on shooting a very high volume of rounds annually, such as 10,000 rounds, professional-grade shotguns like the Benelli M4 or Beretta 1301 are recommended over budget options like the Black Aces S4 due to their presumed greater durability and longevity.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Desk Pop

View all →