7 Most Disappointing Guns 2025 Edition

Published on September 21, 2025
Duration: 17:31

This review from Honest Outlaw details the 7 most disappointing firearms of 2025. The speaker, with over 10 years of experience and 1100+ videos, critically assesses models from Keltec, Benelli, Beretta, Henry, Walther, Jennings, and Sig Sauer, highlighting design flaws, reliability issues, and poor value. The Sig P320 is ranked number one due to ongoing drop-safety concerns and demonstrated failures in extreme drop tests.

Quick Summary

Honest Outlaw identifies the 7 most disappointing firearms of 2025, including the Keltec PR57, Benelli M4 Gen 2, Beretta 92XI SAO Corsa, Henry Big Boy X, Walther WMP SD, Jennings .380, and Sig P320. The Sig P320 tops the list due to persistent drop-safety concerns and failures in rigorous testing, while other models face critiques for design flaws, poor ergonomics, and reliability issues.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction
  2. 01:227. Keltec PR57
  3. 03:596. Benelli M4 Gen 2
  4. 05:525. Beretta 92XI SAO Corsa
  5. 08:264. Henry Big Boy X
  6. 10:313. Walther WMP SD
  7. 13:282. Jennings .380
  8. 15:451. Sig P320

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the 7 most disappointing guns of 2025 according to Honest Outlaw?

The 7 most disappointing guns of 2025 reviewed by Honest Outlaw are the Keltec PR57, Benelli M4 Gen 2, Beretta 92XI SAO Corsa, Henry Big Boy X, Walther WMP SD, Jennings .380, and the Sig P320, with the P320 being ranked number one.

Why is the Sig P320 considered disappointing?

The Sig P320 is disappointing primarily due to ongoing drop-safety controversies. The review highlights poor ergonomics, a high bore axis, and demonstrated failures in extreme drop tests where the firearm did not remain functional or safe.

What are the main criticisms of the Keltec PR57?

The Keltec PR57 is criticized for being 'wildly inconvenient,' featuring a heavy double-action-only trigger, non-adjustable sights, and an internal 21-round magazine loaded via 10-round clips, a system reminiscent of WWI technology.

Which firearms are criticized for quality control issues in the review?

The Henry Big Boy X (.357 Magnum) is criticized for receivers that rust quickly and degrading reliability. The Walther WMP SD (.22 Magnum) is noted for a loose rear sight and an overly complex magazine release system.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Honest Outlaw

View all β†’