Arguing about the HD

Published on May 19, 2025
Duration: 17:11

This video provides an in-depth review of the Staccato HD pistol, discussing its features, performance, and user feedback. The presenter, Ben Stoeger, shares his experience shooting the HD, highlighting its suitability as a 'duty 2011' and its appeal to those seeking a tactical pistol with modern features. The discussion covers common user concerns like the safety mechanism, trigger feel, and ergonomics, while also touching on its availability in California and its potential as a carry option.

Quick Summary

The Staccato HD is a duty-oriented 2011 pistol praised for its balanced feel, fast slide reciprocation, and effective iron sights. While Staccato offers warranty fixes for its safety issue, some users find its ergonomics and Series 80 trigger different from other 2011s. It's noted as a California-compliant option and a 'checklist gun' for tactical users, though its value is debated against simpler firearms like the Glock 47.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to the Staccato HD
  2. 00:11Viewer Comments & Initial Impressions
  3. 01:05Addressing the Safety Issue
  4. 01:35Safety Lever Ergonomics & Function
  5. 02:17Annoyance of Warranty Repairs
  6. 02:30Hot Spot from Safety Pressure
  7. 02:42Positive Feedback & California Love
  8. 03:18FYI: Updated Serial Numbers
  9. 03:37Locating the Serial Number
  10. 04:11Determining if Your HD Needs Update
  11. 04:31Future of Iron Sights Placement
  12. 04:38Iron Sights: Aesthetics vs. Function
  13. 05:22Staccato Offering Cali Compliant Version
  14. 05:502011s for Lefties & Price Point
  15. 05:57Trigger Comparison: Stealth Arms vs. Staccato HD
  16. 06:14Series 80 Trigger Feel
  17. 06:22Ambidextrous Controls Significance
  18. 06:44Gun Condition: 'Wet'
  19. 06:55Rounds Through HD & Balance
  20. 07:05Discomfort Resolution & Weight/Balance Feedback
  21. 07:35Agreeing with Practical Shooting Observations
  22. 07:52Staccato Fanboy Perspective
  23. 08:03Frame Detailing & Build Quality
  24. 08:14Build Quality Details: Mold Seams & Fit
  25. 08:51Duty Staccato: Reliability & Durability Questions
  26. 09:02Positive Initial Impression
  27. 09:19Confirming Safety Flip Issue
  28. 09:23Magazine Lock Back Issues
  29. 09:31Provided Magazines Performance
  30. 10:032011 for Those Who Don't Want a 2011
  31. 10:16Insightful Comment: Checklist Gun
  32. 10:34Duty Pistol vs. 2011 Requirements
  33. 10:55Series 80 Trigger: Added Warmth
  34. 11:13Heroes Discount Application Referral
  35. 11:444-inch vs. 5-inch Barrel Preference
  36. 11:53Fast Reciprocating 4-inch Gun
  37. 12:07Shooting Performance: 20 Yard Targets
  38. 12:40Confidence in Shooting at Distance
  39. 12:42Verdict & Grip Chunky Concern
  40. 12:48Grip is Different: Try Before Buying
  41. 13:00Final Thoughts & Ambivalence
  42. 13:03Target Audience vs. Glock 17/47
  43. 13:13What is the Point of the HD?
  44. 13:20Not a Race-Out 2011, Not Better Than Glock 47
  45. 13:33Glock Simplicity vs. Staccato HD Cost
  46. 14:15Seeing the HD for What It Is
  47. 14:31Target Audience: Teams, Warrants, Aspiring Operators
  48. 14:47Checklist Gun for Specific Users
  49. 14:474.5-inch vs. 4-inch & USPSA
  50. 14:52Not a USPSA Gun
  51. 15:01Other Offerings Better for Games/Carry
  52. 15:16Enthusiast Type of Thing
  53. 15:26Combat Handgun: Best Shooting Out of the Box?
  54. 15:36Expensive Combat Handgun
  55. 15:40How Much Combat Are You Seeing?
  56. 15:48Crazy to Spend 5x for Marginal Improvement
  57. 16:00Manufacturing & Design Differences
  58. 16:11Precision vs. Mass Production
  59. 16:27Funny Comparison: Staccato HD vs. Glock
  60. 16:27Continuing to Shoot the HD
  61. 16:33People Want to Shoot the HD
  62. 16:39Reaction to HD Feel & Trigger
  63. 16:49Different Reaction to Race-Out 2011
  64. 16:56HD: Muted Reaction, More Serious Perception
  65. 17:07Continuing the Review

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main criticisms of the Staccato HD pistol?

The primary criticisms of the Staccato HD include potential issues with the safety lever flipping up during firing, a different feel to the safety ergonomics compared to other 2011s, and a Series 80 trigger that some find less crisp than Series 70 triggers. Some users also find the grip chunky and the overall value proposition questionable when compared to simpler, less expensive firearms like the Glock 47.

What are the positive aspects of the Staccato HD pistol?

Positive aspects of the Staccato HD include its well-balanced feel, fast slide reciprocation, and easy-to-acquire iron sights. Many users appreciate its suitability as a 'duty 2011,' its ambidextrous controls, and its availability as a California-compliant option. The gun is also noted for its solid build quality and reliable performance with its provided magazines.

Does Staccato offer a fix for the safety issue on the HD model?

Yes, Staccato is aware of the safety issue on the HD model and will apply a fix if the firearm is sent in for warranty service. This indicates a commitment from the manufacturer to address reported problems and improve the user experience for owners of the Staccato HD.

What is the significance of serial numbers 2400 and above for the Staccato HD?

Serial numbers 2400 and above are considered the updated versions of the Staccato HD. This suggests that Staccato has implemented improvements or fixes in production batches starting from this serial number range, addressing potential issues found in earlier production runs.

Is the Staccato HD considered a good option for competition shooting?

The Staccato HD is generally not considered an ideal choice for competitive shooting disciplines like USPSA. While it's a capable duty pistol, other firearms in its price range or even less expensive options are often better suited and perform more effectively for competitive applications.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Ben Stoeger

View all →