Benelli M4 vs M4 Clone Shotguns

Published on January 11, 2024
Duration: 15:11

This video provides an expert-level comparison of the Benelli M4 Tactical shotgun against several Turkish-made clones (Ermox X-Defense M4, MAC 1014, Panzer M4 Tactical). Hosts Kaya and Aaron, experienced firearm reviewers, detail the features, historical context, and on-range performance of each model. They highlight the Benelli M4's military adoption and premium price point (approx. $2,000), contrasting it with the more affordable clones that offer similar ergonomics and initial performance. The review includes demonstrations of advanced loading techniques like 'ghost loading' and discusses import capacity restrictions.

Quick Summary

The Benelli M4 Tactical shotgun, costing around $2,000, is compared against its Turkish-made clones (Ermox, MAC, Panzer). While clones offer similar ergonomics and initial performance at a lower price, the Benelli M4 boasts military adoption and proven reliability. Advanced techniques like 'ghost loading' can increase capacity on all models, which are typically import-restricted to 5+1 rounds with 18.5" barrels.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Clash of the Clones
  2. 02:01Benelli M4 Tactical Overview
  3. 02:31Ermox X-Defense M4 Clone
  4. 02:59MAC 1014 Clone
  5. 03:26Panzer M4 Tactical Clone
  6. 04:28Live Fire Testing & Ghost Loading
  7. 11:15Final Comparison & Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between the Benelli M4 Tactical and its clones?

The primary difference lies in price and proven military pedigree. The Benelli M4 Tactical is the original, adopted by military forces, and costs around $2,000. Its clones, such as the Ermox X-Defense M4, MAC 1014, and Panzer M4 Tactical, offer similar ergonomics and initial performance at a significantly lower cost, though long-term reliability requires further testing.

Can the capacity of Benelli M4 clones be increased?

Yes, the 5+1 capacity common on these 12GA semi-auto shotguns is often restricted for import. Advanced techniques like 'ghost loading,' where an extra round is manually inserted into the chamber while the bolt is held open, can increase the effective capacity by one round.

Which shotgun is recommended: the Benelli M4 or its clones?

The recommendation depends on priorities. The Benelli M4 offers proven military reliability but at a high cost. The clones provide a similar feel and function for less money, making them a strong value proposition if their long-term durability proves comparable through extensive use.

What are the key features of the Benelli M4 Tactical and its clones?

All models typically feature an 18.5-inch barrel and a semi-auto, piston gas-operated action firing 12GA ammunition. Clones may offer variations in stock types (adjustable vs. fixed) and charging handle robustness, while the original Benelli M4 is known for its battle-proven reliability and ergonomic design.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from ClassicFirearms

View all →