Best 10mm? SIG Sauer vs. Springfield vs. S&W

Published on August 2, 2022
Duration: 19:32

This comprehensive review, led by Justin Opinion, analyzes three leading 10mm handguns: the SIG Sauer P320-XTEN, Springfield Armory XDM Elite, and Smith & Wesson M&P 10mm. Utilizing objective data from a Mantis recoil sensor and controlled accuracy testing, the video provides detailed insights into recoil management, group sizes at 15 yards, and subjective assessments of ergonomics and trigger performance. The analysis aims to equip viewers with the information needed to select the best 10mm pistol for their needs.

Quick Summary

This expert review compares the SIG Sauer P320-XTEN, Springfield Armory XDM Elite, and S&W M&P 10mm handguns. Objective data from a Mantis recoil sensor and 15-yard accuracy tests show the S&W M&P leading in recoil recovery and the Springfield XDM in group size. The final selection depends on user preference for trigger feel versus grip texture.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Shooting Montage
  2. 01:14Comparison Overview
  3. 01:31Technical Specifications Comparison
  4. 02:12Recoil Testing with Mantis
  5. 03:59Accuracy Testing Methodology
  6. 09:48Accuracy Results Summary
  7. 10:01Subjective Assessment: Ergonomics and Triggers
  8. 16:34Final Conclusions

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the SIG Sauer P320-XTEN, Springfield Armory XDM Elite, and S&W M&P 10mm?

The SIG P320-XTEN, Springfield XDM Elite 4.5", and S&W M&P 10mm all offer 15-round capacity and optics-ready slides. Objectively, the S&W M&P excelled in recoil recovery (0.44s), while the Springfield XDM produced the tightest accuracy group (1.257"). Subjectively, trigger feel and grip texture vary, with the Springfield praised for its trigger but criticized for grip slipperiness, and the S&W vice-versa.

How was the accuracy of the 10mm handguns tested in the video?

Accuracy was tested at 15 yards using a shooting rest to minimize human error. Magtech 180-grain ammunition was used consistently across all firearms. Each gun was fired at its own target to allow for precise measurement of group sizes, with results ranging from 1.257 inches to 1.659 inches.

What role did the Mantis recoil sensor play in the comparison?

The Mantis recoil sensor was used to objectively measure recoil management, specifically focusing on the firearm's recovery time after each shot. This provided quantifiable data on how quickly the muzzle returned to a stable position, aiding in the comparison of felt recoil and shootability between the three 10mm pistols.

Which 10mm handgun is recommended based on the video's findings?

Justin Opinion concludes that all three are excellent 10mm options. The final choice hinges on personal preference, specifically whether the shooter prioritizes a superior trigger feel (Springfield XDM) or a more comfortable grip texture (S&W M&P), as both offer competitive performance otherwise.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Justin Opinion

View all →