Black Powder 31 cal vs 22 LR

Published on November 23, 2020
Duration: 13:25

This video compares the terminal ballistics of a .31 caliber black powder revolver against a modern .22 LR pistol. While the .22 LR showed greater hydraulic displacement in water jugs, the .31 caliber demonstrated more structural damage to soda cans and watermelons. Despite its surprising effectiveness on certain targets, the black powder revolver's slow loading and reliability issues make it impractical for most modern uses.

Quick Summary

The .31 caliber black powder revolver showed surprising effectiveness, causing more structural damage to watermelons than the .22 LR, despite the .22 LR's greater hydraulic displacement in water jugs. However, black powder revolvers are impractical due to slow loading and reliability issues.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: .31 Cal Uberti Colt 1849
  2. 01:13Black Powder Loading Explained
  3. 03:35Introducing the .22 LR Kel-Tec P17
  4. 04:42Water Jug Ballistics Test
  5. 05:51Soda Can & Toilet Paper Tests
  6. 09:13Watermelon Ballistics Test
  7. 12:02Conclusion: Practicality & Winner

Frequently Asked Questions

How does the .31 caliber black powder revolver compare to the .22 LR in ballistic tests?

In water jug tests, the .22 LR showed more hydraulic displacement. However, the .31 caliber demonstrated greater structural damage to soda cans and watermelons, suggesting different types of terminal effects.

What are the practical limitations of using a black powder revolver today?

Black powder revolvers are generally impractical due to their slow reloading process, susceptibility to moisture, and potential for mechanical jams or misfires, making them less reliable than modern firearms.

Which firearm was considered more effective for general targets in the comparison?

The .31 caliber black powder revolver was declared the winner for most targets tested, despite its practical drawbacks. Its performance on tougher materials like watermelons was notably superior to the .22 LR.

What components are needed to load a .31 caliber percussion revolver?

To load a .31 caliber percussion revolver, you need black powder, lead balls specific to the .31 caliber, and percussion caps to ignite the powder charge. Proper loading sequence is crucial for safety and function.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Autumn's Armory

View all →