"BM Bone Collector: Predator" by Nutnfancy

Published on February 15, 2013
Duration: 12:28

This review of the Benchmade 15020 Bone Collector highlights its strengths as a collectible and utility knife, particularly its G10 handle and sheepfoot blade. However, the reviewer finds the blade too heavy and thick for tactical use, and the ergonomics squared off for his preference. The D2 steel is noted as good but not his favorite, and the "Bone Collector" motif is considered overplayed.

Quick Summary

The Benchmade 15020 Bone Collector is a heavy-duty folding knife featuring D2 steel and a G10 handle with a sheepfoot blade. While praised for its collectible appeal and solid Axis lock, the reviewer finds its 6-ounce weight and thickness too much for tactical use, preferring lighter, more ergonomic options for EDC.

Chapters

  1. 00:01Introduction
  2. 00:04Benchmade 15020 Bone Collector
  3. 00:17Knife's History on Nutnfancy
  4. 00:40Reviewer's Blade Dislike
  5. 01:02Philosophy of Use
  6. 01:13Heavy Blade Preference
  7. 01:49Reviewer's EDC Comparison
  8. 02:53Collectibility
  9. 03:16Crux of the Problem: Blade Weight
  10. 03:39Tactical Blade Assessment
  11. 04:01Balance and Steel
  12. 04:07D2 Steel Analysis
  13. 04:35D2 Steel Properties
  14. 04:44Rockwell Hardness
  15. 05:01Sharpening Experience
  16. 05:10Steel Preferences
  17. 05:30Blade Dimensions
  18. 05:39Blade Strength
  19. 05:44Griptilian Comparison
  20. 05:54Bone Collector Logo
  21. 06:01Limited Edition Number
  22. 06:06Bone Collector Motif
  23. 06:18Hunting Equipment Context
  24. 06:35Motif Overplay
  25. 06:44Blade Shape and Grind
  26. 06:55Deployment Hole
  27. 07:09Deployment Access
  28. 07:15Deployment Speed
  29. 07:22Stop Pin and Lockup
  30. 07:25Axis Lock
  31. 07:47Handle Construction Criticism
  32. 07:51Handle Ergonomics
  33. 07:54Milled Liners
  34. 08:11Liner Material
  35. 08:14G10 Handle Pattern
  36. 08:22Handle Feel
  37. 08:25Traction for Tactical Use
  38. 08:32Liner Gimping
  39. 08:45Defensive Use Consideration
  40. 08:51Handle Width
  41. 08:59Ergonomics Rundown
  42. 09:03Benchmade Clip
  43. 09:17Clip Reversibility
  44. 09:23Ambidextrous Design
  45. 09:27Lanyard Hole
  46. 09:30Backspacer Material
  47. 09:41Blade Centering
  48. 09:44Handle Retention
  49. 09:49Durability
  50. 09:52Competitive Options
  51. 09:54Hogue Allen Elisha EX1
  52. 10:37Hogue EX1 Price and Steel
  53. 10:50Hogue EX1 Gimping
  54. 10:56Benchmade Triage 915
  55. 11:05Triage Weight and Steel
  56. 11:11Triage Appearance
  57. 11:14Triage Sharpness
  58. 11:16Rescue Cutter
  59. 11:21Triage Lock Type
  60. 11:28Triage vs. 15020 Carry Preference
  61. 11:30Triage Thickness
  62. 11:35Triage vs. 15020 Thickness
  63. 11:38Benchmade Griptilian 550HG
  64. 11:42Griptilian Weight
  65. 11:46Blade Comparison
  66. 11:49Side-by-Side Comparison
  67. 11:54Blade Similarity
  68. 11:57Blade Finish Preference
  69. 12:04Grind Striations
  70. 12:05Grip Thickness
  71. 12:10Grip Thickness Comparison
  72. 12:14Grip vs. Bone Collector Thickness
  73. 12:14Grip vs. Bone Collector Price
  74. 12:21Review Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main criticisms of the Benchmade 15020 Bone Collector?

The primary criticisms of the Benchmade 15020 Bone Collector from the reviewer are its excessive weight (6 ounces) and thickness, making it less suitable for tactical use. He also finds the handle ergonomics squared off and lacking sufficient traction, and considers the "Bone Collector" motif to be overplayed.

What type of steel is used in the Benchmade 15020 Bone Collector?

The Benchmade 15020 Bone Collector reviewed features D2 steel. This is described as a semi-stainless tool steel with high hardness, typically measuring 60-62 on the Rockwell scale, known for good edge retention but potentially being harder to sharpen.

How does the Benchmade 15020 Bone Collector compare to the Benchmade Griptilian 550HG?

The Benchmade Griptilian 550HG is significantly lighter (3.8 oz vs. 6 oz) and cheaper than the 15020 Bone Collector. While their blades are almost identical in size and shape, the reviewer prefers the finish on the Griptilian and notes the Bone Collector is thicker.

What is the reviewer's opinion on the Benchmade 15020 Bone Collector's handle and ergonomics?

The reviewer finds the handle of the Benchmade 15020 Bone Collector to be a criticism. While hand-filling, he describes it as a bit squared off and lacking adequate traction for tactical applications. He also notes the presence of milled liners to reduce weight, which is a positive aspect.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from nutnfancy

View all →