Choosing Your First Black Powder Revolver

Published on October 18, 2021
Duration: 13:33

This video provides an expert overview of choosing a first black powder revolver, with a strong recommendation for the 1851 Colt Navy Reproduction. The instructor, Dustin, details common models from Uberti and Pietta, discusses the pros and cons of steel vs. brass frames, and explains differences in sights and handling between Colt and Remington designs. The advice is practical and geared towards new shooters in the cap-and-ball hobby.

Quick Summary

The 1851 Colt Navy Reproduction is the top recommendation for a first black powder revolver. It offers a balance of affordability (around $250), manageable powder capacity (15-25 grains), light recoil, and ease of use, making it an excellent choice for new enthusiasts entering the cap-and-ball hobby.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to Black Powder Revolvers
  2. 00:27Common Reproduction Models
  3. 02:43Colt Walker Reproduction
  4. 03:54Colt Dragoon Reproduction
  5. 04:191860 Colt Army Reproduction
  6. 05:141851 Colt Navy - Top Recommendation
  7. 06:17Remington New Model Army
  8. 07:57Uberti vs. Pietta Comparison
  9. 10:06Steel vs. Brass Frames
  10. 11:07Sights and Point of Aim

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best black powder revolver for a beginner?

The 1851 Colt Navy Reproduction is highly recommended for beginners. It's affordable (around $250), uses less powder (15-25 grains), has light recoil, and is generally easier for new shooters to handle and enjoy.

What are the main differences between Uberti and Pietta black powder revolvers?

Uberti often provides better finishes and more discreet markings on their reproductions. Pietta tends to use stiffer springs, which can lead to fewer "cap jams" and more reliable ignition, though their actions might feel rougher.

Should I choose a steel frame or a brass frame for my black powder revolver?

For longevity and safety, especially with frequent use, steel frames are strongly recommended. Brass frames are cheaper but can "stretch" or indent over time, potentially leading to safety concerns.

Why is the Colt Walker not recommended as a first black powder revolver?

The Colt Walker reproduction is not ideal for beginners due to its significant weight (nearly 5 lbs), high cost ($400-$450), and large powder capacity (up to 60 grains), making it cumbersome and expensive to shoot.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Guns of the West

View all →