Compact Pistol Showdown: Smith & Wesson vs Shadow Systems

Published on August 8, 2024
Duration: 26:37

This video provides a comprehensive head-to-head comparison of the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp and the Shadow Systems MR920P. The review covers common features, differences, pros, cons, and performance during live-fire drills. The instructor highlights aspects like magazine capacity, slide serrations, optic mounting, and trigger feel, offering insights into which pistol might be a better value and performer for the end-user.

Quick Summary

The Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp offers excellent value, costing around $250 less than the Shadow Systems MR920P while providing comparable shooting performance, flat-shooting characteristics, and recoil reduction. Although the MR920P has a factory magwell and direct optic mounting, the M&P's lower price, better slide serrations, and Picatinny rail make it a superior choice for budget-conscious buyers.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: M&P Carry Comp vs Shadow Systems MR920P
  2. 00:15Pistol Overview & Common Features
  3. 01:13Frame Size & Magazine Capacity
  4. 02:43Compensator Design & Barrel Length
  5. 03:50Slide Serrations & Sights
  6. 04:38Price Comparison & Value
  7. 05:34Optics Mounting Systems
  8. 06:07Reliability & Track Record
  9. 06:35Trigger Feel & Performance
  10. 07:18Live Fire: M&P Carry Comp Drills
  11. 10:57Live Fire: Shadow Systems MR920P Drills
  12. 14:40Recoil Comparison
  13. 18:33Slide Stop/Release Lever Issues
  14. 20:33Target Analysis & Overall Performance
  15. 22:07Final Verdict & Recommendation
  16. 23:07Detailed Trigger Breakdown
  17. 25:05Conclusion: Which Pistol to Buy?

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp and the Shadow Systems MR920P?

The M&P Carry Comp is approximately $250 cheaper, features a Picatinny rail, and has slightly better slide serrations. The MR920P includes a magwell out of the box and offers optic mounting without plates, but lacks iron sight co-witness with its optic system.

Which pistol, the M&P Carry Comp or MR920P, shoots flatter and reduces recoil better?

Both pistols shoot very flat and offer comparable recoil reduction. While the MR920P has a larger port, the M&P Carry Comp performs just as well, with the instructor finding they shot the M&P slightly better overall.

How do the triggers compare on the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp and Shadow Systems MR920P?

The M&P Carry Comp's trigger has a gritty take-up but a crisp break, which the instructor slightly preferred. The MR920P has smoother take-up and a lighter break, but the M&P's overall feel was deemed better by the reviewer.

Is the Smith & Wesson M&P Carry Comp a better value than the Shadow Systems MR920P?

Yes, the M&P Carry Comp is considered a better value. It costs significantly less and offers comparable performance, features, and shootability, allowing for upgrades like sights and magazines while still remaining cheaper.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Hunt Fish Shoot

View all →