Correcting Gun Myths w/ Bloke on the Range: StGs, Carbines, and M16s

Published on October 16, 2023
Duration: 16:44

This video debunks three common firearm myths: the AK-47 being a direct copy of the StG-44, Mattel manufacturing the M16, and the M1 Carbine lacking stopping power. It highlights significant mechanical differences between the AK-47 and StG-44, clarifies the M16's production history, and uses ballistic data to refute claims about the M1 Carbine's effectiveness.

Quick Summary

The AK-47 and StG-44 differ mechanically: the AK uses a rotating bolt (M1 Garand influence), while the StG uses a tilting bolt. The myth of Mattel producing M16 parts is false; it likely stems from the rifle's plastic feel. The M1 Carbine's .30 Carbine round shows superior penetration to .45 ACP in tests.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Video Premise
  2. 00:45Myth 1: AK-47 vs StG-44 Design
  3. 07:00Myth 2: Mattel & The M16
  4. 10:20Myth 3: M1 Carbine Stopping Power

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main mechanical differences between the AK-47 and the StG-44?

The AK-47 utilizes a rotating bolt system, influenced by the M1 Garand, for its operation. In contrast, the StG-44 employs a tilting bolt mechanism. These distinct designs highlight significant differences despite some visual similarities.

Is it true that Mattel manufactured parts for the M16 rifle?

No, there is no evidence that Mattel manufactured any parts for the M16 rifle. This myth likely arose from the M16's lightweight plastic components, which felt different from older, heavier firearms, and possibly from toy versions.

Did the M1 Carbine's .30 Carbine round lack stopping power in Korea?

Ballistic tests show the .30 Carbine round has better penetration than the .45 ACP. Combat reports of 'failures' are often attributed to stress-induced aiming errors or soldiers diving for cover after being hit, not the round's inherent power.

Who are the hosts of the 'Correcting Gun Myths' video on Forgotten Weapons?

The video features Ian McCollum from Forgotten Weapons and Bloke on the Range. They are collaborating to debunk common misconceptions about historical firearms, building on a previous joint effort.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →