Dan Wesson ECP 1911 vs. Wilson Combat XTAC Alloy Compact 1911

Published on October 5, 2024
Duration: 14:31

This video provides a detailed comparison between the Dan Wesson ECP 1911 and the Wilson Combat XTAC Alloy Compact 1911, focusing on their suitability for concealed carry. The presenter highlights differences in frame size, grip length, magazine capacity, and specific features like checkering, bobtail frames, and beaver tail grip safeties. Technical aspects such as barrel feed ramp design, finishes, and trigger characteristics are also discussed, offering insights for potential buyers.

Quick Summary

The Dan Wesson ECP and Wilson Combat XTAC Alloy Compact 1911s offer distinct advantages for concealed carry. The XTAC's Officer-size frame enhances concealability, while the ECP's fully ramped barrel protects its alloy frame and its bobtail grip reduces printing. Both feature quality triggers and reliable performance, making the choice dependent on individual priorities for size, features, and price.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: ECP vs. XTAC Compact 1911s
  2. 00:14Frame Size Differences: Commander vs. Officer
  3. 00:21Magazine Capacity and Types
  4. 00:41Chip McCormick Magazines
  5. 01:36Wilson Combat XTAC Alloy Compact Overview
  6. 02:07Concealability: Officer vs. Commander Frame
  7. 02:17Wilson Combat Magwell and Grip
  8. 02:53Checkering and Mainspring Housing: ECP vs. XTAC
  9. 03:04Bobtail vs. Magwell Design
  10. 03:11Beaver Tail Grip Safety Comparison
  11. 03:19Hammer and Finish: ECP Features
  12. 04:06Grip Safety Activation and Sensitivity
  13. 05:15Trigger Comparison: Pad vs. Flat Face
  14. 05:31Trigger Pull and Reset: ECP
  15. 05:52Safety and Magazine Release
  16. 06:17Forged Parts and Finishes: DLC vs. Duty Coat
  17. 06:36Alloy Frames and Feed Ramp Design
  18. 06:46Dan Wesson ECP Ramped Barrel
  19. 07:01Wilson Combat Traditional Feed Ramp
  20. 07:28Recoil Springs and Barrel Life
  21. 07:46Slide and Ejection Port Design
  22. 07:59Sights: Brass Bead vs. AmerGlo
  23. 08:14Thin vs. Standard Profile Grips
  24. 08:31Wilson Combat Ambi Safety
  25. 08:49Wilson Combat Sights and Slide Profile
  26. 09:04Melted Edges and Rear Slide Serrations
  27. 09:19Wilson Combat Trigger Pull and Reset
  28. 09:42Wilson Combat Hammer: Retro Commander Ring
  29. 09:50Ball Cuts vs. Slab Side Slide
  30. 10:07Barrel Length and Holster Options
  31. 10:11Kramer Leather Holster
  32. 10:38Galco Commander Holster
  33. 11:01Inspiration: Video Games and Compact 1911s
  34. 11:14Uncharted and The Last of Us Influence
  35. 11:42Previous Compact 1911 Experience
  36. 12:14Wilson Combat Carry Size 1911
  37. 12:24Trigger Pull Weight Comparison
  38. 12:57Blem Dan Wesson Models
  39. 13:17Best 1911 Magazine Brands
  40. 13:43Conclusion: Superb Concealed Carry Options
  41. 13:56Price Comparison: ECP vs. Wilson Combat
  42. 14:08Dan Wesson ECP Price and Sights
  43. 14:15Video Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Dan Wesson ECP and the Wilson Combat XTAC Alloy Compact 1911s for concealed carry?

The primary differences lie in their frame sizes: the ECP uses a Commander frame for a slightly longer grip, while the XTAC features a more concealable Officer-size compact frame. The ECP also boasts a fully ramped barrel for alloy frame protection, and a bobtail grip for reduced printing, whereas the XTAC offers a more traditional design with a magwell.

How do the triggers compare on the Dan Wesson ECP and Wilson Combat XTAC Alloy Compact 1911s?

The Wilson Combat XTAC's trigger is a medium-length pad, breaking crisply around 3.5 lbs with a good reset. The Dan Wesson ECP features a flat-faced, square-profile trigger with a pull weight closer to 5 lbs, which is still considered excellent for self-defense due to its crispness and defined wall.

Which 1911 is better for concealed carry, the Dan Wesson ECP or the Wilson Combat XTAC Alloy Compact?

For maximum concealability, the Wilson Combat XTAC Alloy Compact with its Officer-size frame is generally preferred. However, the Dan Wesson ECP's bobtail grip and slightly slimmer profile also contribute significantly to its concealment capabilities, making both strong contenders depending on user preference.

What are the key design features that differentiate the Dan Wesson ECP's barrel and frame from the Wilson Combat XTAC?

The Dan Wesson ECP features a fully ramped barrel designed to protect its alloy frame from potential damage by hollow-point ammunition. The Wilson Combat XTAC uses a more traditional, Colt Defender-style design, which, while functional, may be more susceptible to frame gouging over time with certain ammunition types.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from BERETTA9mmUSA

View all →