FN 15 Guardian vs. M&P 15 SPORT III - Brutal Honest Truth 🫣

Published on March 5, 2024
Duration: 18:38

This video provides a direct comparison between the FN 15 Guardian and the Smith & Wesson M&P Sport III, two budget-friendly AR-15 platforms. The reviewer highlights their very similar specifications, including barrel length, handguard type, and weight. Key differences noted are the FN's aggressive pistol grip and the M&P's smoother trigger, which is identified as a significant advantage. Ultimately, the M&P Sport III is recommended for its superior trigger and overall feel, despite the FN's aesthetically pleasing handguard.

Quick Summary

The Smith & Wesson M&P Sport III is recommended over the FN 15 Guardian primarily due to its significantly superior trigger quality. While both rifles share similar specifications, the FN's trigger is described as 'horrendous,' whereas the M&P's is much smoother and more pleasant to shoot, making it the better choice for overall performance and user experience.

Chapters

  1. 00:14Introduction and Range Setup
  2. 00:19Interest in Rifle Comparison
  3. 01:03FN 15 Guardian Overview
  4. 01:13Smith & Wesson M&P Sport III Overview
  5. 01:26Comparing Specifications
  6. 02:00FN 15 Guardian Detailed Specs
  7. 03:01FN 15 Guardian Stock Adjustment Issue
  8. 03:23Optics on FN 15 Guardian
  9. 03:29Smith & Wesson M&P Sport III Detailed Specs
  10. 03:42M&P Sport III M-LOK and Grip
  11. 04:02Adjustable Stock and Sling Rings
  12. 04:25Weight Comparison Recap
  13. 04:37Ergonomic and Aesthetic Comparison
  14. 04:58Ammunition Used: Hornady Frontier
  15. 05:32Shooting the FN 15 Guardian First
  16. 06:11FN 15 Guardian Firing Impressions
  17. 06:38FN 15 Guardian Trigger Complaint
  18. 07:45FN 15 Guardian Clear and Safe
  19. 07:58Shooting the Smith & Wesson M&P Sport III
  20. 08:17M&P Sport III First Magazine Impressions
  21. 09:19M&P Sport III Firing Impressions
  22. 09:45M&P Sport III Trigger Advantage
  23. 09:52M&P Sport III Clear and Safe
  24. 10:17Mid-Conclusion: M&P Feels Lighter, Better Trigger
  25. 10:48FN Grip Feels Nicer
  26. 11:07Honest Opinion Preview
  27. 11:17Speeding Up Shots for Final Assessment
  28. 12:26Speeding Up Shots: FN 15 Guardian
  29. 12:59FN 15 Guardian Trigger Limitation
  30. 13:22FN 15 Guardian Clear and Safe
  31. 13:39Speeding Up Shots: Smith & Wesson M&P Sport III
  32. 13:50M&P Sport III Heat Observation
  33. 14:34M&P Sport III Clear and Safe
  34. 14:40Heat Comparison: Both Warm
  35. 14:53Final Magazine for the Winner
  36. 15:00Review Summary and Winner Announcement
  37. 15:10Smith & Wesson M&P Sport III Wins
  38. 16:11FN Fell Short This Round
  39. 16:25FN's Budget Approach Criticized
  40. 17:12Smith & Wesson's Improvements
  41. 17:36Kudos to Smith & Wesson Upgrades
  42. 18:03Viewer Opinions Requested
  43. 18:18Support the Channel: Yo Gang Merch
  44. 18:30Closing Remarks

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the FN 15 Guardian and the Smith & Wesson M&P Sport III?

While nearly identical in specifications like barrel length and handguard, the key difference lies in the trigger. The FN 15 Guardian has a 'horrendous' trigger, while the M&P Sport III's trigger is significantly smoother and better, making it the preferred choice for most shooters.

Which rifle feels lighter, the FN 15 Guardian or the M&P Sport III?

The Smith & Wesson M&P Sport III generally feels lighter than the FN 15 Guardian. This is attributed to its slightly lower weight (6.5 lbs vs 6.6 lbs) and potentially the optics used during the comparison, contributing to a more manageable handling experience.

How is the pistol grip on the FN 15 Guardian compared to the M&P Sport III?

The FN 15 Guardian features a more aggressive and enjoyable pistol grip that the reviewer has been enjoying. In contrast, the M&P Sport III has a grip with a finger slot but is described as less aggressive.

Is the stock adjustment difficult on the FN 15 Guardian?

Yes, the adjustable stock on the FN 15 Guardian can be quite stiff and difficult to adjust. The reviewer mentions that applying a bit of oil might help improve its movement and ease of adjustment.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Yoki Sturrup

View all →