Glock 17 vs 1911 9mm

Published on March 29, 2017
Duration: 12:40

This video provides an expert comparison between the Glock 17 Gen 3 and a 9mm Springfield 1911, drawing on the reviewer's extensive experience. The Glock excels in reliability, CCW suitability due to weight and capacity, and survival scenarios. The 1911 is favored for its superior accuracy, trigger, aesthetics, and home defense potential, especially with a light. Ultimately, the Glock is chosen for its overall versatility.

Quick Summary

From an expert perspective, the Glock 17 Gen 3 excels in reliability, CCW suitability due to its lighter weight (25 oz) and higher capacity (17+1), and survival scenarios. The 9mm 1911, while heavier (30-45 oz) with lower capacity (9+1), is favored for its superior single-action trigger, accuracy, aesthetics, and home defense potential, especially with a light.

Chapters

  1. 00:12Introduction: Glock 17 vs 1911 9mm
  2. 01:28Historical Context: 1911 vs Glock
  3. 02:31Reliability and Maintenance
  4. 03:39Accuracy and Trigger Mechanics
  5. 05:41Aftermarket and Accessories
  6. 06:14Concealed Carry (CCW) Comparison
  7. 07:01Home Defense Considerations
  8. 08:29Range Use and Plinking
  9. 10:17Survival (SHTF) Scenario
  10. 11:27Final Verdict

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Glock 17 Gen 3 and a 9mm 1911?

The Glock 17 Gen 3 is lighter (25 oz) with higher capacity (17+1) and a striker-fired trigger, making it ideal for CCW and survival. The 9mm 1911 is heavier (30-45 oz) with lower capacity (9+1) and a superior single-action trigger, favored for accuracy, home defense, and range fun.

Which pistol is better for concealed carry (CCW) between the Glock 17 and 1911?

The Glock 17 is generally preferred for CCW due to its significantly lighter weight (25 oz vs. 30-45 oz) and higher magazine capacity (17+1 vs. 9+1), making it more comfortable for daily carry.

How do the triggers of the Glock 17 and 1911 compare?

The 1911 typically features a superior single-action trigger, known for its crisp and light pull, contributing to better accuracy. The Glock 17 uses a striker-fired 'fulcrum' trigger, which is consistent but often described as mushier.

What are the maintenance requirements for a Glock 17 versus a 1911?

Glocks are renowned for extreme reliability with minimal maintenance. While a 1911 can be equally reliable, it requires more frequent cleaning and lubrication to ensure optimal performance compared to the more forgiving Glock platform.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Honest Outlaw

View all →