Gun Guys – Ep. 06: Full-size vs Compact 1911's

Published on May 21, 2018
Duration: 6:46

This video compares full-size and compact 1911 pistols, highlighting historical reliability challenges with compacts due to shorter dwell times and slide mass. Modern Wilson Combat compacts have overcome these issues, offering improved reliability. Compacts can also offer reduced perceived recoil and better shooting for those with changing eyesight, with 9mm being a consideration for grip strength limitations.

Quick Summary

Modern compact 1911s, particularly from manufacturers like Wilson Combat, have overcome historical reliability issues. These advancements address challenges with dwell time and slide mass, offering consistent performance comparable to full-size models, while potentially providing benefits like reduced perceived recoil and better handling for those with changing eyesight.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: Full-Size vs Compact 1911
  2. 01:12Compact 1911 Reliability Issues Explained
  3. 02:19Modern Compact 1911 Reliability Breakthroughs
  4. 03:38Sight Radius & Aging Eyesight
  5. 04:38Recoil Perception: Compact vs Full-Size
  6. 05:29Caliber & Grip: .45 ACP vs 9mm Compacts

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between full-size and compact 1911 pistols?

Full-size 1911s typically have a 5-inch barrel and are known for historical reliability. Compact models are smaller, potentially offering easier concealed carry and reduced perceived recoil, but historically faced reliability challenges due to shorter dwell times.

Have compact 1911s become more reliable over time?

Yes, manufacturers like Wilson Combat have significantly improved compact 1911 reliability over the last decade. Modern designs have overcome previous issues related to slide mass and dwell time, leading to consistent performance.

How does sight radius affect shooting, especially with aging eyesight?

A shorter sight radius on compact pistols can actually benefit shooters experiencing changes in close-in vision. While longer sight radii are traditionally preferred for precision, a compact's shorter radius can become easier to focus on.

Is a 9mm or .45 ACP better for a compact 1911?

For shooters with grip strength or hand size limitations, a 9mm compact 1911 is often recommended over a .45 ACP. The .45 ACP can be more challenging to control effectively in a smaller, lighter frame.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Wilson Combat

View all →