GX vs GY: What Are the Differences in Pedersen's Garands?

Published on August 20, 2016
Duration: 13:17

This video from Forgotten Weapons delves into the rare Pedersen GX and GY rifles, prototypes developed in 1939 as John Pedersen's final attempt to influence US military rifle adoption. Expertly presented by Ian McCollum, the analysis highlights key differences in their gas systems (GX's 'gas trap' vs. GY's 'gas port') and clip compatibility (GX's proprietary clip vs. GY's standard M1 Garand en bloc clips). The GY represents a refinement towards military standardization, while the GX retains earlier design elements. Production was extremely limited, with only about 10-12 of each model ever made.

Quick Summary

The Pedersen GX and GY rifles, developed in 1939, represent John Pedersen's final attempts at military adoption. Key differences include the GX's muzzle 'gas trap' and proprietary clip versus the GY's more reliable 'gas port' system and standard M1 Garand clips. These rare prototypes, with only 10-12 of each made, also featured modifications to prevent 'Garand thumb'.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to Pedersen's Garands
  2. 02:25Difference 1: En Bloc Clips
  3. 03:12Mechanical Improvements (Anti-Garand Thumb)
  4. 06:08Difference 2: Gas Systems (Trap vs. Port)
  5. 09:39Historical Context and Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Pedersen GX and GY rifles?

The primary differences lie in their gas systems and clip compatibility. The GX uses an early 'gas trap' system at the muzzle and a proprietary clip, while the GY features a more reliable 'gas port' system and accepts standard M1 Garand en bloc clips.

Why did John Pedersen develop the GX and GY rifles?

John Pedersen developed the GX and GY rifles in 1939 as his final attempt to have his semi-automatic rifle design adopted by the U.S. military, refining elements of the M1 Garand.

What mechanical improvements did Pedersen make to avoid 'Garand thumb'?

Pedersen separated the operating rod spring from the feed spring and modified the clip release. This modification ensures the bolt stays locked back after a clip is inserted, requiring manual release to prevent 'Garand thumb'.

How rare are the Pedersen GX and GY rifles?

Both the Pedersen GX and GY are exceptionally rare prototypes. Only approximately 10 to 12 examples of each model were ever produced, making them highly sought-after historical firearms.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →