H&k P30SK vs. FN FNS-9C

Published on May 11, 2016
Duration: 30:17

This comprehensive comparison between the Heckler & Koch P30SK and the FN FNS-9C, presented by Justin Opinion, details key technical specifications, functional differences, and user experience. The review highlights the P30SK as a hammer-fired pistol with a more spongy trigger and European-style paddle magazine release, while the FNS-9C is a striker-fired pistol with a crisper trigger and a more traditional, albeit problematic for the reviewer, magazine release. Both are noted for their ambidextrous controls and are considered strong contenders in the compact 9mm market, with specific ergonomic and capacity differences discussed.

Quick Summary

The HK P30SK is a hammer-fired pistol with a spongier trigger and European paddle mag release, while the FN FNS-9C is striker-fired with a crisper trigger and a traditional button mag release. The FNS-9C offers higher standard magazine capacity (12 vs 10 rounds) and comes with an extended magazine, while the P30SK is highly customizable and preferred by the reviewer for concealed carry.

Chapters

  1. 00:31Introduction & Specs Comparison
  2. 01:52Magazine Capacity Differences
  3. 02:37Hammer-Fired vs. Striker-Fired
  4. 03:06Sight Pictures & Preferences
  5. 04:39Customization Options
  6. 05:06Trigger Feel & Measurements
  7. 06:06FNS-9C Magazine Options & Grip
  8. 07:01FNS-9C Magazine Release Issues
  9. 08:20FNS-9C Recoil Handling & Bore Axis
  10. 09:26HK P30SK Overview & Features
  11. 10:00P30SK Magazine Capacity & Grip
  12. 10:30P30SK Sight Picture & Trigger
  13. 11:06P30SK Grip & Reset
  14. 11:25P30SK Paddle Magazine Release
  15. 11:55P30SK Higher Capacity Magazine Options
  16. 12:51Range Test: FNS-9C Accuracy
  17. 14:42Range Test: P30SK Accuracy
  18. 16:33Range Test: FNS-9C (Remington UMC)
  19. 18:26Range Test: P30SK (Remington UMC)
  20. 19:46Ergonomics & Grip Texture Comparison
  21. 20:30FNS-9C Grip Texture & Front Lines
  22. 21:22Control Placement & Ambidexterity
  23. 22:50Customization Options (Backstraps/Panels)
  24. 23:25Field Stripping Comparison: HK vs FN
  25. 25:21Brass Shaping on FNS-9C Magazine
  26. 25:56Barrel Rifling: Polygonal vs. Traditional
  27. 26:29Reassembly Process
  28. 27:13Final Verdict & Carry Preference
  29. 28:25Miscellaneous Features (Trigger Guard, Rail)
  30. 29:00Conclusion: Both are Good Choices

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the HK P30SK and FN FNS-9C?

The HK P30SK is hammer-fired with a spongier trigger and European paddle mag release, while the FN FNS-9C is striker-fired with a crisper trigger and a traditional, though reviewer-disliked, button mag release. The FNS-9C has a higher standard magazine capacity (12 vs 10 rounds).

Which pistol has better ergonomics for concealed carry?

The reviewer finds the HK P30SK to be more suitable for extensive concealed carry due to its overall reliability and preferred ergonomics, particularly noting issues with the FNS-9C's magazine release that make it less ideal for carry.

What are the trigger characteristics of the HK P30SK and FN FNS-9C?

The FN FNS-9C features a crisper, nicer striker-fired trigger with a short, tactile reset, averaging around 6 pounds. The HK P30SK, being hammer-fired, has a longer, spongier travel but a light break, averaging about 5 pounds 10 ounces.

Can you customize the HK P30SK and FN FNS-9C?

The HK P30SK offers significant customization with interchangeable backstraps and side grip panels, allowing for at least 8 configurations. The FNS-9C has limited customization, primarily differing in slide finish.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Justin Opinion

View all →