Hand Fit 1911 vs. Machine Fit 1911 (Worth Changing my EDC?)

Published on November 15, 2018
Duration: 12:56

The Yankee Marshal compares a machine-fit Sig Sauer STX 1911 to a hand-fit Dan Wesson Specialist, ultimately choosing the latter for his EDC. Key differences include the Specialist's tighter tolerances, crisper 3.2 lb trigger pull (vs. STX's 4.6 lb), and superior ergonomics like larger safeties and a tactical sight ledge. While both are reliable, the hand-fit nature of the Dan Wesson provides a more refined feel and action.

Quick Summary

A hand-fit 1911, like the Dan Wesson Specialist, offers tighter tolerances and a smoother action compared to a machine-fit pistol such as the Sig Sauer STX. The Specialist also boasts a crisper 3.2 lb trigger pull and improved ergonomics, making it a superior choice for EDC.

Chapters

  1. 00:00EDC Philosophy & Changes
  2. 02:16Switching 1911 Models: STX vs Specialist
  3. 03:21Feature Similarities
  4. 04:06Technical Differences: Slides, Rails, Sights
  5. 06:02Extractors and Guide Rods
  6. 07:41Safety and Ergonomics Comparison
  7. 09:10Hand Fit vs. Machine Fit Explained
  8. 09:58Trigger Comparison & EDC Decision

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between a hand-fit and a machine-fit 1911?

A hand-fit 1911, like the Dan Wesson Specialist, typically features tighter tolerances, flush-fitting parts, and a smoother action due to meticulous manual fitting by a gunsmith. A machine-fit 1911, such as the Sig Sauer STX, uses looser tolerances and automated processes, which can result in less refined operation but often lower cost.

Why did The Yankee Marshal switch his EDC from a Sig Sauer STX to a Dan Wesson Specialist?

He switched because he found the Dan Wesson Specialist to be a superior firearm, particularly noting its tighter hand-fit tolerances, crisper 3.2 lb trigger pull, and improved ergonomics like larger safeties and a tactical sight ledge, making it a better choice for his everyday carry.

How does the trigger pull weight compare between the Sig Sauer STX and Dan Wesson Specialist?

The Sig Sauer STX, a Series 80 design, has a trigger pull of approximately 4 lbs 9 oz. The Dan Wesson Specialist, a Series 70 design, offers a much lighter and crisper trigger pull at 3 lbs 2 oz, which is a significant factor in its selection as a preferred EDC.

What ergonomic advantages does the Dan Wesson Specialist offer over the Sig Sauer STX?

The Dan Wesson Specialist features larger, bar-stock ambidextrous thumb safeties that are easier to manipulate and provide a better thumb platform. It also includes an accessory rail for added weight and balance, and its fixed sights have a tactical ledge for one-handed slide manipulation.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →