Hk VP9-L vs. Walther Q5 Match

Published on September 19, 2019
Duration: 32:52

This video provides a detailed comparison between the Walther Q5 Match and the HK VP9 Long Slide, focusing on their performance in accuracy testing and handling. The reviewer, Justin Opinion, highlights key differences in trigger pull, ergonomics, and overall shooting experience. While both are considered excellent polymer-framed competition handguns, the Q5 Match is ultimately favored for its superior trigger, perceived better value, and optic-ready slide.

Quick Summary

The Walther Q5 Match and HK VP9 Long Slide are both 9mm striker-fired pistols with 5-inch barrels. The Q5 Match features a lighter trigger pull (~4.5 lbs vs ~5.5 lbs for the VP9), a lower MSRP ($849 vs $1168 for the VP9 with slide kit), and comes optic-ready. While ergonomics and sights are similar, the Q5 Match is favored for its value and trigger.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Accuracy Testing Setup
  2. 00:32Walther Q5 Match Warm-up
  3. 01:13HK VP9 Long Slide First Shots
  4. 02:06VP9 Long Slide Sight Picture Observation
  5. 02:44Return to Walther Q5 Match
  6. 03:0515-Yard Target Observation
  7. 03:25Ergonomics and Sights Comparison
  8. 03:45Shooting Tree Challenge
  9. 04:11VP9 Long Slide Six O'Clock Hold
  10. 04:26Q5 Match Polymer Frame Mention
  11. 04:41Q5 Match Shooting Tree Attempt
  12. 05:20Third Mag Through VP9 Long Slide
  13. 06:09VP9 Long Slide High Shooting Observation
  14. 06:25Sight Adjustment Discussion
  15. 06:28Head-to-Head By The Numbers
  16. 07:04Weight Comparison
  17. 07:12Rifling and Sights
  18. 07:20Striker-Fired and Action Type
  19. 07:27Magazine Count Discussion
  20. 08:00Thickness Comparison
  21. 08:12Trigger Pull Difference
  22. 08:33Grip Index Comparison
  23. 08:50MSRP Discussion
  24. 09:44VP9 Long Slide Sight Adjustment
  25. 10:00VP9 Long Slide Shooting Tree Attempt
  26. 10:06Ammunition Variety
  27. 10:31HK VP9 L Shooting Tree
  28. 11:00Target Observation Issues
  29. 11:43Post-Shot Analysis: VP9 Long Slide
  30. 12:50VP9 Long Slide Re-attempt
  31. 14:05Walther Q5 Match Re-attempt
  32. 14:07PPQ Platform Familiarity
  33. 14:36Q5 Match Ergonomics and Trigger
  34. 14:42Q5 Match Stock Sights
  35. 15:38Shooting Performance Comparison
  36. 16:01Detailed Look at Q5 Match
  37. 16:14Q5 Match Built on PPQ Platform
  38. 16:42Q5 Match Optic Ready
  39. 17:00Slide Lightning Cuts
  40. 17:13Q5 Match Blue Trigger
  41. 17:32Grip and Controls
  42. 17:56Detailed Look at VP9
  43. 18:07VP9 Long Slide Preference
  44. 18:13VP9 Trigger vs PPQ
  45. 18:23VP9 Ergonomics
  46. 18:31VP9 Sights
  47. 19:02VP9 Dialed In
  48. 19:06VP9 Ambidextrous Controls
  49. 19:13VP9 European Magazine Release
  50. 19:55VP9 Cocking Ears and Indicator
  51. 20:39Safety Glasses Reminder
  52. 21:01Return to Q5 Match
  53. 21:32Q5 Match Dialed In Feeling
  54. 21:48VP9 Ergonomics vs Q5
  55. 22:01Trigger Improvement Discussion
  56. 22:17Combined Factors for Shooting Performance
  57. 22:40Walther Q5 Match Final Thoughts
  58. 23:11Testing with Crappy Ammo
  59. 23:58VP9 with Steel Cased Ammo
  60. 24:24VP9 Steel Cased Ammo Results
  61. 24:29Q5 Match with Steel Cased Ammo
  62. 25:01Magazine Release Confusion
  63. 25:10HK Back to Practice
  64. 25:25VP9 Malfunction: Failure to Extract
  65. 25:47Q5 Match with Steel Cased Ammo (Continued)
  66. 26:07Q5 Match Reliability with Steel Ammo
  67. 26:22Correction: Q5 M2 Design
  68. 26:47Offhand Comparison Accuracy Testing
  69. 27:04Accuracy Testing at 11 Yards
  70. 27:37Q5 Match Accuracy Test
  71. 29:29HK VP9 Long Slide Accuracy Test
  72. 29:41Final Comparison & Verdict
  73. 30:31Picking a Favorite
  74. 30:53Cost and Value Recap
  75. 31:01Optic Ready Comparison
  76. 31:34Conclusion: Better Pistol and Value

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Walther Q5 Match and the HK VP9 Long Slide?

The Walther Q5 Match and HK VP9 Long Slide are both 9mm striker-fired pistols with 5-inch barrels. Key differences include trigger pull weight (Q5 Match is lighter at ~4.5 lbs vs VP9 at ~5.5 lbs), MSRP (Q5 Match is significantly lower), and the Q5 Match comes optic-ready while the VP9 Long Slide does not. Ergonomics and sights are very similar.

Which pistol has a better trigger, the Walther Q5 Match or the HK VP9 Long Slide?

The Walther Q5 Match is generally considered to have a superior trigger pull. Measured at around 4 pounds 7 ounces, it's lighter and crisper than the HK VP9 Long Slide's trigger, which averaged 5 pounds 6.5 ounces. This difference is noticeable and contributes to the reviewer's preference for the Q5 Match.

How do the Walther Q5 Match and HK VP9 Long Slide compare in terms of price and value?

The Walther Q5 Match has a lower MSRP of $849 and is optic-ready. The HK VP9 Long Slide requires purchasing a base VP9 ($719) plus a slide kit ($449), totaling $1168 MSRP. For these reasons, the Q5 Match is considered to offer better overall value and a lower entry cost.

What are the physical specifications of the Walther Q5 Match and HK VP9 Long Slide?

Both pistols are 9mm with 5-inch barrels. The Walther Q5 Match is 8.1 inches long and weighs 23 ounces. The HK VP9 Long Slide is 8.2 inches long and weighs 26.9 ounces. They have virtually identical sights and similar widths (around 1.3 inches).

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Justin Opinion

View all →