I Tested a REAL Police Glock 17 (500 Rounds Later…)

Published on January 5, 2026
Duration: 9:58

This video details a 500-round reliability test of a used Glock 17 Gen 3, formerly owned by a police officer. The test highlights the firearm's performance with various magazines, noting a single failure-to-feed malfunction and intermittent slide lock-back issues with non-Glock magazines. The reviewer also discusses ergonomic considerations, trigger feel, and potential aftermarket upgrades for this popular pistol.

Quick Summary

During a 500-round test, a police trade-in Glock 17 Gen 3 exhibited one failure to feed malfunction and intermittent slide lock-back issues with non-Glock magazines. The reviewer noted the stock grip texture could be improved and the magazine release was challenging for smaller hands, suggesting aftermarket upgrades for optimal performance.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Police Glock 17 Test
  2. 00:21Initial Firing and Accuracy Check
  3. 00:37One-Shot Reload Drills
  4. 00:48150 Rounds Down: Performance and Issues
  5. 01:09Magazine Variety and Slide Lock Issues
  6. 01:11Glock 17 Gen 3: Bone Stock and Upgrades
  7. 01:30Magazine Release Ergonomics
  8. 01:57Continuing the Test
  9. 02:02Malfunction: Failure to Feed
  10. 02:17Magpul Magazine Issues
  11. 02:51KCI Magazine Slide Lock Issues
  12. 03:10400 Rounds Down: Grip and Sights
  13. 03:41Trigger Pull Assessment
  14. 03:54Iron Sights vs. Red Dots for Police
  15. 04:14Glock Grip Technique Explained
  16. 04:51Final 100 Rounds
  17. 05:00Duty Holster Draw: Blade Tech Valor
  18. 06:26Final Magazine and Results
  19. 06:45500 Round Test Conclusion
  20. 06:56Malfunction Summary: Failure to Feed & Slide Lock
  21. 07:30Recommendation: Is the Glock 17 Gen 3 Worth It?
  22. 07:37Glock Generations: Gen 3 vs. Gen 6
  23. 07:53Price Point: Police Trade-In Value
  24. 08:25What to Change: Red Dot, Mag Release, Grip
  25. 09:04Final Thoughts on Upgrades and Trust
  26. 09:41Upcoming Reviews: Other Police Pistols

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the main reliability issues encountered during the 500-round test of the Glock 17 Gen 3?

The primary malfunction was a single failure to feed. Additionally, the slide failed to lock back on the last round multiple times, particularly when using KCI and Magpul magazines, though Glock magazines performed more reliably in this regard.

How did the ergonomics of the Glock 17 Gen 3 fare during the test?

The grip has functional grooves and an undercut for a secure hold. However, the texture was found to be lacking, and the magazine release button was difficult to operate without breaking grip, suggesting aftermarket upgrades could be beneficial.

Is a used Glock 17 Gen 3 police trade-in a good option for a home defense firearm?

Yes, a used Glock 17 Gen 3 police trade-in is considered a great option for home defense due to its proven reliability, affordability, and the brand's trusted reputation, even if it lacks modern features like optic cuts.

What modifications does the reviewer suggest for a Glock 17 Gen 3?

The reviewer strongly recommends milling the slide for a red dot optic, replacing the magazine release with an extended version for easier manipulation, and improving grip texture through stippling or aftermarket grip pads.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from 1st Shot Tactical

View all →