Lever Action Rifle vs Semi Auto AR-15 Range Review & Speed Test

Published on June 8, 2017
Duration: 15:44

This review compares a Henry lever-action rifle against an AR-15 (S&W M&P 15-22) using .22 LR for a speed test. The AR-15 significantly outperformed the lever action in speed drills and reloads, taking less than half the time for shooting and less than a tenth for reloads. While the AR-15 is technically superior, the lever action may have better legal optics due to its less aggressive appearance.

Quick Summary

In a speed test comparing a Henry lever-action rifle and an AR-15 (S&W M&P 15-22) using .22 LR, the AR-15 was twice as fast in shooting drills and significantly faster in reloads (under 4s vs over 40s). The lever action is also harder to operate effectively from the prone position.

Chapters

  1. 00:08Intro: Lever Action vs AR-15 (.22 LR)
  2. 01:31Historical Prone Shooting Difficulty
  3. 02:16Ballistics & Magazine Design
  4. 04:29Speed Test: Standing Comparison
  5. 06:44Reload Speed: Major Difference
  6. 10:29Prone Shooting Test Results
  7. 12:26Final Assessment & Legal Optics

Frequently Asked Questions

How did the AR-15 perform against the lever-action rifle in speed tests?

In speed tests using .22 LR, the AR-15 (S&W M&P 15-22) consistently outperformed the Henry lever action. It was roughly twice as fast in target transitions and split times, demonstrating a significant advantage in rapid shooting.

What was the difference in reloading times between the two rifle types?

The difference in reloading was dramatic. The AR-15's detachable box magazine reload took under 4 seconds, while the Henry's tubular magazine reload exceeded 40 seconds, highlighting a major disadvantage for the lever action in sustained use.

Is a lever-action rifle harder to shoot from the prone position?

Yes, the prone shooting test confirmed this. Operating a lever action from prone requires the shooter to break their cheek weld and lift their body to cycle the action, unlike the AR-15 which allows for a continuous sight picture.

What are the 'legal optics' of lever-action rifles versus AR-15s?

The host suggests that while the AR-15 is technically superior, a lever-action rifle might have 'better optics' in a courtroom. Its appearance is generally perceived as less aggressive and tactical compared to an AR-15, potentially influencing jury perception.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Honest Outlaw

View all →