M&P Shield vs Ruger LC9S Pro...Who Has The Edge?

Published on February 23, 2015
Duration: 35:09

This video provides a detailed comparison between the Ruger LC9s Pro and the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield, focusing on their suitability for concealed carry. The presenter, Hegshot87, highlights key differences in weight, grip size, slide serrations, trigger characteristics, and magazine handling. While both are considered excellent options, the LC9s Pro is favored for its trigger and lighter weight, whereas the Shield is praised for its aesthetics and slightly better ergonomics for larger hands. The video includes shooting demonstrations and discusses price points and warranties.

Quick Summary

The Ruger LC9s Pro is lighter (17.2 oz) and generally easier to carry than the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield (19 oz). While the Shield offers a slightly larger grip and a clean trigger break, the LC9s Pro is favored by the presenter for its preferred trigger feel and smoother magazine insertion. Both are excellent concealed carry options, with price and personal preference being key deciding factors.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Comparison Setup
  2. 01:09Included Accessories
  3. 03:51Key Features and Differences
  4. 05:51Loaded Chamber Indicators and Safeties
  5. 06:55Rails and Controls
  6. 07:05Magazine Release and Insertion
  7. 09:31Trigger Comparison
  8. 12:44Shooting Demonstration and Malfunctions
  9. 13:30Live Fire Comparison
  10. 17:15M&P Shield Shooting
  11. 19:05LC9s Pro Shooting
  12. 20:44Shooting Results Analysis
  13. 23:38Camera Issues and Outro
  14. 24:06Price Point Comparison
  15. 24:45Warranty Comparison
  16. 25:40Recoil Impulse
  17. 26:23Disassembly Guide: LC9s Pro
  18. 28:08Disassembly Guide: M&P Shield
  19. 29:08Concealed Carry Comfort
  20. 30:59Comparison with Glock 42
  21. 33:15Which Gun is Better?
  22. 34:00Recommendation: Try Before You Buy
  23. 34:43Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Ruger LC9s Pro and the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield for concealed carry?

The Ruger LC9s Pro is lighter (17.2 oz) than the M&P Shield (19 oz). The LC9s Pro has a more aggressive slide serration and a preferred trigger feel for the presenter, while the Shield offers a slightly larger grip and a cleaner, though heavier, trigger break. Magazine insertion is easier on the LC9s Pro.

Which firearm is easier to carry, the Ruger LC9s Pro or the S&W M&P Shield?

The Ruger LC9s Pro is generally considered easier to carry due to its lighter weight (17.2 oz vs. 19 oz for the Shield). Holster style also plays a significant role; a hybrid holster can make the Shield more comfortable, but the LC9s Pro's inherent lightness gives it an edge.

How do the triggers of the Ruger LC9s Pro and S&W M&P Shield compare?

The LC9s Pro trigger has a slight creep before a crisp break around 5 lbs and a full reset. The M&P Shield trigger is heavier (around 6.5 lbs) with no creep, breaking cleanly, but its reset has two distinct clicks, with the second being the actual reset. The presenter prefers the LC9s Pro's trigger feel.

What are the typical price points for the Ruger LC9s Pro and the S&W M&P Shield?

The Ruger LC9s Pro typically retails around $350. The Smith & Wesson M&P Shield is usually around $425, but can often be found on sale for $350-$360, making them competitively priced.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Hegshot87

View all →