M&P Shield Vs Walther PPS

Published on January 1, 2016
Duration: 41:45

This video provides a detailed comparison between the Walther PPS and the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield, focusing on their features, specifications, shooting performance, and pros/cons for concealed carry. The presenter highlights differences in included accessories, ergonomics, magazine release mechanisms, and trigger characteristics. While both are presented as reliable defensive pistols, the reviewer expresses a personal preference for the M&P Shield due to its comfort and concealability, despite acknowledging the PPS's strong performance and options. The video also includes a basic breakdown and reassembly guide for both firearms.

Quick Summary

The Walther PPS and M&P Shield are both reliable compact pistols for concealed carry. The PPS offers more customization like a rail and interchangeable backstraps, while the Shield is lighter, thinner, and has a larger aftermarket. Both require a break-in period due to initial stiffness, and trigger feel differs, with the PPS having a more positive reset.

Chapters

  1. 00:29Intro & New Year Wishes
  2. 00:48Walther PPS vs. M&P Shield Comparison Intro
  3. 01:31Walther PPS Out of the Box
  4. 03:14M&P Shield Out of the Box
  5. 03:41Walther PPS Features
  6. 07:50M&P Shield Features
  7. 11:20Firearm Specifications Comparison
  8. 12:44Size Comparison
  9. 14:04Unique Features & Market Position
  10. 14:46Breakdown Procedure
  11. 19:03Shooting Demonstration
  12. 25:31Shooting Group Analysis
  13. 28:17Trigger Comparison
  14. 29:59Walther PPS Pros & Cons
  15. 32:01M&P Shield Pros & Cons
  16. 33:46Common Cons (Stiffness)
  17. 34:32Walther PPS Specific Cons
  18. 35:39M&P Shield Specific Cons
  19. 37:12Overall Summary & Reliability
  20. 38:17Which One is Better?
  21. 39:04Personal Preference & Carry Choice
  22. 41:24Viewer Feedback & Outro

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Walther PPS and the M&P Shield?

The Walther PPS offers more features like a rail, ambidextrous paddle magazine release, and interchangeable backstraps. The M&P Shield is generally lighter, thinner, and has a larger aftermarket support for accessories like sights and triggers. Both are reliable compact pistols suitable for concealed carry.

Which pistol is better for concealed carry, the Walther PPS or the M&P Shield?

The M&P Shield is often preferred for concealed carry due to its slightly thinner profile and lighter weight, making it more comfortable for all-day carry. However, the Walther PPS is also very concealable and offers more customization options out of the box.

How do the triggers compare on the Walther PPS and M&P Shield?

The Walther PPS has a trigger pull around 6.1 lbs with a positive reset. The M&P Shield's trigger is around 6.5 lbs, featuring a crisp break but a less distinct 'ghost reset.' The PPS trigger is generally considered to have a more defined reset.

Are the Walther PPS and M&P Shield easy to rack?

Both pistols are described as stiff firearms out of the box, requiring a break-in period of several hundred rounds to loosen up. Racking the slide can require significant effort initially for both models.

What are the pros and cons of the Walther PPS?

Pros include its shooting performance, price drop making it affordable, customization options (backstraps, rail), and reliability. Cons can be the magazine release placement, a sharp trigger after extended shooting, and initial stiffness. The PPS M2 is also coming soon.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Hegshot87

View all →