M2 Carbine vs MP44 Sturmgewehr (w/ John Keene)

Published on August 30, 2025
Duration: 12:06

This expert analysis compares the M2 Carbine and MP44 Sturmgewehr for a modern infantry role, drawing on insights from firearms experts Ian McCollum and John Keene. Key considerations include cartridge effectiveness, weight, reliability in various conditions, ergonomics, and market value, highlighting trade-offs between the two iconic firearms. The discussion emphasizes practical engagement ranges and operational nuances relevant to military applications.

Quick Summary

Experts Ian McCollum and John Keene compare the M2 Carbine and MP44 Sturmgewehr for modern infantry roles. The M2 Carbine is favored for its lighter weight (5.2 lbs vs. 10.2 lbs) and handiness, making it practical for typical engagement ranges under 100 yards. The MP44 offers a more powerful cartridge (7.92x33mm Kurz) and better environmental sealing, but at a significant weight penalty and higher market cost.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Scenario
  2. 00:55Keene's Choice: MP44 Sturmgewehr
  3. 01:38Ian's Choice: M2 Carbine
  4. 02:38Ballistics and Engagement Range
  5. 03:18Reliability and Environmental Resistance
  6. 05:23Operational Considerations
  7. 08:32Reliability and Stopping Power
  8. 11:14Market Value and Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

Which rifle is better for modern infantry: the M2 Carbine or the MP44 Sturmgewehr?

Experts suggest the M2 Carbine offers advantages in lighter weight and handiness for modern infantry roles, while the MP44 Sturmgewehr excels with its more powerful intermediate cartridge and better environmental sealing. The choice depends on prioritizing mobility versus raw power and protection at typical engagement ranges.

What are the key differences in ballistics and reliability between the M2 Carbine and MP44 Sturmgewehr?

The MP44's 7.92x33mm Kurz cartridge is more potent than the M2 Carbine's .30 Carbine, offering better armor penetration. However, the M2 is significantly lighter. Reliability-wise, the MP44's dust cover provides better protection against contaminants than the M2's open action, though M2 reliability can be maintained with fresh parts.

How do the M2 Carbine and MP44 Sturmgewehr compare in terms of weight and ergonomics?

The M2 Carbine is considerably lighter, weighing around 5.2 lbs, compared to the MP44 Sturmgewehr at approximately 10.2 lbs. This weight difference significantly impacts mobility and fatigue during prolonged use. Ergonomic preferences vary, but the MP44's longer magazine can pose challenges when shooting prone.

What is the market value difference between the M2 Carbine and MP44 Sturmgewehr?

Historically and in auction settings, the MP44 Sturmgewehr typically commands a price roughly double that of the M2 Carbine. This reflects its status as a pioneering assault rifle and its rarity compared to the M2 Carbine.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →