My Shield Arms Gen 1, 2, and 3 Experience

Published on May 28, 2023
Duration: 5:34

Tessah Booth shares her extensive experience with Shield Arms S15 magazines for the Glock 48, detailing failures with Gen 1 20-round models due to manufacturing defects. She reports significantly improved reliability with Gen 2 and initial positive impressions of Gen 3, despite finish wear concerns. Booth emphasizes personal risk assessment for concealed carry and recommends thorough testing of all gear.

Quick Summary

Tessah Booth reports significant improvements in Shield Arms S15 magazines from Gen 1 to Gen 3 for the Glock 48. While Gen 1 20-round mags failed catastrophically, Gen 2 and Gen 3 have shown high reliability, though finish wear remains a concern. She stresses personal testing for concealed carry.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Shield Arms Magazine Introduction
  2. 00:16Video Overview & Mag Generations
  3. 00:31Gen 1 Magazine Failures
  4. 01:21Second Gen 1 Failure & Replacement
  5. 01:50Gen 1 15-Round Mags & Usage
  6. 02:14Gen 2 Magazine Performance
  7. 02:47Risk Assessment & Training Use
  8. 03:13Gen 2 Finish Quality
  9. 03:21Gen 3 Magazine First Impressions
  10. 03:46Gen 3 Manufacturer & Design Changes
  11. 04:26Gen 3 Finish Comparison
  12. 04:59Conclusion & Personal Disclaimer

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the main issues with Shield Arms Gen 1 magazines for the Glock 48?

The primary issue with Shield Arms Gen 1 20-round magazines was catastrophic failure, where the basepad would shear off. This was attributed by Shield Arms to a 'bad heat-treated batch' of magazines. The 15-round Gen 1 magazines did not experience these failures.

How reliable are Shield Arms Gen 2 magazines for the Glock 48?

Shield Arms Gen 2 magazines have demonstrated high reliability, with approximately 4,000 rounds fired through multiple units. The reviewer experienced only a single, unreplicable failure-to-feed, with no other malfunctions or catastrophic failures reported.

What are the key design changes in Shield Arms Gen 3 magazines?

Shield Arms Gen 3 magazines feature a new US-based manufacturer, added dimples to the back for better seating, slightly thicker steel, and a black nitride coating. These changes aim to improve durability and address past quality control issues.

What is the recommended approach for using aftermarket magazines like Shield Arms S15 for concealed carry?

The speaker strongly advises personal risk assessment and thorough testing of any gear, especially aftermarket magazines, before carrying them for concealed defense. Extensive range time and drills are crucial to ensure reliability with your specific firearm.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Tessah Booth

View all →