Polymer Revolvers? What's The Point?

Published on June 20, 2012
Duration: 5:16

The speaker, a self-proclaimed revolver enthusiast, questions the necessity and long-term viability of polymer-framed revolvers like the Ruger LCR and Taurus offerings. He highlights concerns about mixed materials (polymer, aluminum, steel) leading to potential cracking and uneven wear, and argues that they don't offer significant weight savings over existing lightweight aluminum or scandium-framed revolvers from manufacturers like Smith & Wesson. He suggests these alternatives are more proven, streamlined, and potentially better value.

Quick Summary

The speaker questions the necessity of polymer-framed revolvers, citing concerns about mixed materials (polymer, aluminum, steel) potentially leading to cracking and uneven wear. He argues that lightweight aluminum or scandium-framed revolvers from manufacturers like Smith & Wesson offer better alternatives, being more streamlined, proven, and not significantly heavier.

Chapters

  1. 00:04Introduction: Revolver Guy's Opinion
  2. 00:10Polymer Revolvers: Ruger LCR & Taurus
  3. 00:30Reasons for Skepticism: Material Concerns
  4. 00:44Mixed Materials: Polymer, Aluminum, Steel
  5. 01:08Preference for Solid Material Frames
  6. 01:16Weight Savings Questioned
  7. 01:35Longevity Concerns
  8. 01:47Better Alternatives on the Market
  9. 02:10Smith & Wesson Lightweight Options
  10. 02:16Smith & Wesson 637: Aluminum Frame
  11. 02:46Weight Comparison: LCR vs. S&W 637
  12. 02:51Ideal Carry Caliber: .38 Special +P
  13. 03:07Smith & Wesson 360: Scandium Frame
  14. 03:15Price Comparison: LCR vs. S&W 360
  15. 03:40Why Need a Polymer Gun?
  16. 03:43Trigger Advantage: Double-Action vs. Single-Action
  17. 04:06Conclusion: No Need for Polymer Revolvers
  18. 04:13Problem Already Solved: Metal Frames
  19. 04:20Final Thoughts on Polymer Revolvers

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main concerns with polymer-framed revolvers?

The primary concerns with polymer-framed revolvers include potential long-term durability issues due to mixed materials (polymer, aluminum, steel) with different stress tolerances, leading to cracking or uneven wear. Additionally, they are often perceived as bulkier and not significantly lighter than existing metal-framed alternatives.

What are considered better alternatives to polymer revolvers for concealed carry?

Lightweight revolvers with aluminum or scandium frames, such as the Smith & Wesson 637 or 360, are considered better alternatives. These models are often more streamlined, proven in terms of durability, and can offer comparable or better weight savings without the material concerns of polymer frames.

Is there a weight advantage to polymer revolvers?

According to the speaker, polymer revolvers do not offer a significant weight advantage. They are often perceived as bulky and not as streamlined as lightweight metal-framed revolvers, which can achieve similar or better weight reductions without the potential material integrity issues.

What is the recommended caliber and ammunition for small carry revolvers?

For small revolvers intended for concealed carry, the speaker recommends .38 Special +P ammunition. He specifically advises using loads that are specially formulated for snub-nosed guns, as these tend to yield the best results for this type of firearm.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →