Red Dot + Magnifier vs Low Power Variable Optic (1-6x)

Published on August 1, 2017
Duration: 6:11

This review compares Low Power Variable Optics (LPVOs) with Red Dot Sights paired with Magnifiers for AR-15 platforms. The speaker, Garand Thumb, draws on extensive experience (18,000+ rounds) to highlight that LPVOs offer variable magnification up to 6x but can suffer from scope shadow. Red dot/magnifier combos excel in speed and flexibility, especially in awkward positions, but may have inferior glass quality. The choice depends heavily on the intended use: red dots for close-quarters urban environments and LPVOs for longer-range engagements.

Quick Summary

For urban environments and engagements under 200 meters, a red dot with a magnifier is preferred for speed and flexibility due to no eye relief requirements. For open terrain or distances over 200 meters, an LPVO's superior magnification and clarity are better suited.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: LPVO vs. Red Dot Debate
  2. 00:51Speaker's Experience & Gear
  3. 01:21LPVO Characteristics & Drawbacks
  4. 02:31Red Dot + Magnifier Pros & Cons
  5. 03:26Mission-Based Optic Selection
  6. 04:53Weight Comparison & Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main advantage of a red dot sight with a magnifier compared to an LPVO?

A red dot sight with a magnifier excels in flexibility and speed, especially in awkward shooting positions, as it requires no specific eye relief. This makes it ideal for close-quarters or dynamic scenarios where precise head placement is difficult.

What are the drawbacks of using an LPVO for close-range shooting?

While LPVOs can function at 1x magnification, they may suffer from 'scope shadow' if the shooter's eye isn't perfectly aligned behind the optic. This can be a disadvantage during fast-paced shooting or when adopting unconventional stances.

When is an LPVO a better choice than a red dot and magnifier?

An LPVO is generally preferred for engagements at distances over 200 meters or in open terrain. Its superior magnification range (up to 6x) and typically better optical clarity and field of view provide an advantage for identifying and engaging targets at longer ranges.

How do the weights of LPVOs and Red Dot/Magnifier setups compare?

The weight difference is relatively minor. An EOTech red dot with a G33 magnifier typically weighs around 22.4 ounces, while a 1-6x LPVO mounted with a quality mount like Geissele's weighs approximately 25-27 ounces.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Garand Thumb

View all →