Revolving Carbines: Things To Know

Published on March 6, 2023
Duration: 9:28

This video provides a detailed comparison and review of two revolving carbines: the Uberti 1858 Remington New Army Carbine (cap and ball) and the Heritage Rough Rider Rancher (22 LR). The presenter, Dustin from Guns of the West, discusses the comfort, accuracy, and safety considerations of each, highlighting the Remington's uncomfortable stock and the Heritage's superior ergonomics. Key differences in loading mechanisms, materials, and price points are also explored, with both carbines praised for their unique aesthetics and conversation-starting potential.

Quick Summary

Revolving carbines like the Uberti 1858 Remington and Heritage Rough Rider Rancher offer unique aesthetics but come with handling considerations. The Remington's sharp stock is uncomfortable, while the Heritage is more ergonomic. Safety concerns include escaping gases and blowback particles, requiring shooter awareness and protection.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to Revolving Carbines
  2. 00:27Featured Carbines: Uberti Remington & Heritage Rancher
  3. 00:47Comfort and Handling: Is it Awkward?
  4. 00:57Uberti Remington 1858 Comfort Issues
  5. 02:07Heritage Rough Rider Rancher Comfort
  6. 02:55Accuracy of Revolving Carbines
  7. 04:00Safety: Hand Placement Reminder
  8. 04:35Pros and Cons of Revolving Carbines
  9. 04:41Cons: Gas Escape and Particle Return
  10. 05:50Pros: Uniqueness and Aesthetics
  11. 06:50Side-by-Side Comparison
  12. 07:03Stock Comparison: Comfort and Material
  13. 07:37Trigger Guard and Grip Hook
  14. 07:46Loading Mechanisms: Cap & Ball vs. Cartridge
  15. 08:15Sling Mounts and Ejector
  16. 08:24Rear and Front Sights
  17. 08:27Barrel Length and Finish
  18. 08:50Conclusion and Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

Are revolving carbines comfortable to shoot?

Comfort varies significantly. The Uberti 1858 Remington New Army Carbine's sharp stock can be uncomfortable, especially for taller shooters. The Heritage Rough Rider Rancher, with its smooth stock pad, offers superior comfort, making it feel more like a traditional rifle in this regard.

How does the handling of a revolving carbine affect accuracy?

Compared to traditional rifles, revolving carbines may be less stable due to their design. However, when viewed as a handgun with a shoulder stock, the added stability makes them easier to shoot accurately than handguns alone.

What are the main safety concerns with revolving carbines?

Key safety issues include escaping gases and lead particles from the cylinder gap, which can be dangerous. Additionally, particles can blow back onto the shooter's face, causing stinging or even breaking the skin, necessitating protective gear.

What is the difference between the Uberti Remington and Heritage Rancher carbines?

The Uberti Remington is a cap and ball reproduction with a sharp stock and 18-inch barrel, costing $500-$600. The Heritage Rancher uses modern 22 LR cartridges, has a comfortable stock, a 16-inch barrel, and costs $200-$250.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Guns of the West

View all →