Rifle and Pistol Pairings part 7 - Underwood M1 Carbine and Smith and Wesson Military and Police 38

Published on January 6, 2024
Duration: 7:50

This video reviews a 1947 Underwood M1 Carbine in .30 Carbine and a 1927 Smith & Wesson Military and Police .38 Special revolver. The presenter discusses the historical context of the M1 Carbine as a replacement for the M1911 for support troops and compares the .30 Carbine round to a '357 Magnum Slim'. The S&W revolver, a police trade-in from Northbridge, MA, is noted for its smooth trigger and excellent condition despite its age. The pairing is chosen for aesthetic appeal and historical context, rather than direct tactical synergy.

Quick Summary

The M1 Carbine was designed as a lighter, quicker-firing replacement for the M1911 pistol for support troops. Its .30 Carbine round is comparable to a '357 Magnum Slim' in muzzle velocity, and a 1927 Smith & Wesson Military and Police .38 Special revolver is highlighted for its smooth trigger and historical significance.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to Rifle and Pistol Pairings Part 7
  2. 00:14Featuring the Underwood M1 Carbine and S&W M&P .38 Special
  3. 00:16Underwood M1 Carbine (1947, .30 Carbine)
  4. 00:24Smith & Wesson Military and Police .38 Special (1927)
  5. 00:34Challenges in Pairing and Historical Context
  6. 01:07.30 Carbine Round vs. .357 Magnum
  7. 01:32.30 Carbine Projectile Grain Weight
  8. 02:14Detailed Look at the 1927 S&W M&P .38 Special
  9. 02:30Northbridge Police Department Connection
  10. 02:44Refinished Condition and Age of the Revolver
  11. 02:55Design and Features of Vintage S&W Revolvers
  12. 03:07Reasoning for Pairing S&W M&P with M1 Carbine
  13. 03:38Troop Weaponry and Personal Firearms
  14. 04:05Aesthetic Appeal of the Pairing
  15. 04:46Condition and Smoothness of the S&W Revolver
  16. 05:11Imagining a Beat Cop with the Revolver
  17. 05:28Refinishing of the S&W Revolver
  18. 05:31Experience Buying the M1 Carbine
  19. 05:51Discussion on Universal M1 Carbines
  20. 06:36Value and Condition of the Underwood M1 Carbine
  21. 06:57Final Thoughts on the Pairing
  22. 07:08Underwood M1 Carbine and S&W M&P Pair Well
  23. 07:17Thank You and Channel Milestones
  24. 07:35Closing Remarks and Support for 2A Rights

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the historical significance of the M1 Carbine in relation to the M1911 pistol?

The M1 Carbine was developed to replace the M1911 pistol for rear-echelon troops, support personnel, and those in confined spaces like helicopters, offering a lighter weapon with increased range and stopping power.

How does the .30 Carbine round compare ballistically to the .357 Magnum?

The .30 Carbine round is often compared to a '357 Magnum Slim' due to similar muzzle velocities. Both rounds can utilize the same powder and pistol primers in handloading.

What are the key features of the 1927 Smith & Wesson Military and Police .38 Special revolver?

The 1927 S&W M&P .38 Special, also known as a Hand Ejector, features a smooth trigger, good target sights, and an effective ejection rod. This particular example was a police trade-in and is noted for its excellent condition.

What are potential issues with Universal M1 Carbines?

Later models of Universal M1 Carbines, often featuring metal handguards with ventilation holes, are sometimes described as unreliable. They may have dual recoil springs that don't always function well, and parts may not interchange with original military M1 Carbines.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Cranky Gun Reviews

View all →