Ruger SR1911 CMD vs S&W 625 JM

Published on July 25, 2014
Duration: 26:41

This video provides a detailed comparison between the Ruger SR1911 CMD and the Smith & Wesson 625 JM, both chambered in .45 ACP. The presenter, Justin Opinion, highlights their similarities in material and American heritage, while contrasting their fundamental design as a semi-automatic versus a revolver. The review includes practical shooting impressions, accuracy testing at 10 yards, and chronograph data for muzzle velocity, offering insights into their performance and handling characteristics.

Quick Summary

The Ruger SR1911 CMD and Smith & Wesson 625 JM are compared, highlighting their .45 ACP caliber, stainless steel construction, and American heritage. Key differences include the SR1911's semi-automatic action versus the 625 JM's revolver design, with the S&W offering superior adjustable sights. Accuracy tests at 10 yards favored the 625 JM, and chronograph data revealed velocity differences.

Chapters

  1. 00:52Introduction to .45 ACP
  2. 01:47American Craftsmanship
  3. 03:17Comparing the Ruger SR1911 and S&W 625
  4. 03:53Ruger SR1911 CMD Specs
  5. 04:01Smith & Wesson 625 JM Specs
  6. 04:12Construction and Weight Comparison
  7. 05:35Shooting the Ruger SR1911 CMD
  8. 06:09Shooting the Smith & Wesson 625 JM
  9. 07:1910 Yard Accuracy Test Setup
  10. 08:50S&W 625 JM Accuracy Results
  11. 10:09Ruger SR1911 CMD Accuracy Test
  12. 11:14Ruger SR1911 CMD Accuracy Results
  13. 12:14Accuracy Comparison Summary
  14. 12:44Chronograph Test Setup
  15. 13:51S&W 625 JM Chronograph Results (Freedom Munitions)
  16. 15:42S&W 625 JM Chronograph Results (Reloads)
  17. 16:53Ruger SR1911 CMD Chronograph Results (Reloads)
  18. 17:40Ruger SR1911 CMD Chronograph Results (Freedom Munitions)
  19. 18:19Overall Shooting Comparison
  20. 18:54Similarities and Differences
  21. 20:07Cleaning and Capacity Advantages
  22. 21:01Sight Radius Comparison
  23. 21:44Sight Adjustability Comparison
  24. 21:59Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Ruger SR1911 CMD and the Smith & Wesson 625 JM?

The primary difference lies in their action type: the Ruger SR1911 CMD is a semi-automatic pistol, while the Smith & Wesson 625 JM is a revolver. Both are chambered in .45 ACP and made of stainless steel, but the S&W 625 JM offers adjustable rear sights for both windage and elevation, whereas the SR1911 is windage-adjustable only.

How did the Ruger SR1911 CMD and S&W 625 JM perform in accuracy tests?

In a 10-yard accuracy test, the Smith & Wesson 625 JM demonstrated slightly better accuracy and consistency, placing shots more on the point of aim. The Ruger SR1911 CMD also produced respectable groups, though it was noted as being slightly less precise in this comparison.

What were the muzzle velocity results for the .45 ACP ammunition fired from these firearms?

Using Freedom Munitions .45 ACP 230-grain FMJ, the S&W 625 JM averaged 817 fps, and the Ruger SR1911 CMD averaged 718 fps. With the presenter's reloads, the 625 JM averaged 804 fps, and the SR1911 CMD averaged 754 fps.

Which firearm is easier to clean and offers higher capacity?

The revolver, the Smith & Wesson 625 JM, is generally easier to clean. The semi-automatic Ruger SR1911 CMD offers a capacity advantage, as its magazine capacity can be increased with aftermarket options, unlike a revolver's fixed cylinder capacity.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Justin Opinion

View all →