S&W M&P 5" Review | Does Barrel Length Matter?

Published on October 5, 2024
Duration: 9:54

This review compares the Smith & Wesson M&P 5-inch and 4.25-inch variants, focusing on how barrel length affects pistol performance. The speaker, an experienced shooter with thousands of rounds through both models, finds the 5-inch version offers a smoother recoil impulse and slightly better concealment due to its slide profile, while the 4.25-inch model allows for faster target transitions. The review emphasizes that for most practical handgun applications, especially self-defense at close ranges, training is a far more significant factor than barrel length.

Quick Summary

The 5-inch Smith & Wesson M&P pistol provides a smoother recoil impulse and better balance than its 4.25-inch counterpart, with the extended slide aiding concealment. While barrel length differences are noticeable, especially in recoil and follow-up shots, the speaker stresses that for practical handgun applications like self-defense, training is the most critical factor, not barrel length.

Chapters

  1. 00:14Introduction & Video Plan
  2. 00:53Does Barrel Length Matter in Pistols?
  3. 01:29M&P 5" Review & Initial Impressions
  4. 02:08Transition from Glock to Smith & Wesson
  5. 02:39Reliability: Out-of-Box vs. After Cleaning
  6. 04:08Weight and Balance of the 5" M&P
  7. 04:44Recoil Impulse Comparison (5" vs 4.25")
  8. 05:45Trigger Discussion (OEM vs. Apex)
  9. 06:14Thumb Safety & Grip Module
  10. 06:31Concealment Comparison
  11. 06:55Does Barrel Length Matter for Handguns?
  12. 07:46Barrel Length & Sight Radius vs. Red Dots
  13. 08:06Velocity Differences (4.25" vs 5")
  14. 08:33Practical Differences at 5 Yards
  15. 08:57The Importance of Training
  16. 09:11Viewer Questions & Engagement

Frequently Asked Questions

How does the 5-inch S&W M&P compare to the 4.25-inch model in terms of recoil?

The 5-inch S&W M&P offers a noticeably smoother and softer recoil impulse compared to the 4.25-inch version. This is attributed to the extended barrel and increased slide material, which helps absorb more of the 'snap' during firing, making it feel less mechanical.

Does barrel length significantly impact handgun performance for self-defense?

For most practical self-defense distances (3-10 yards), barrel length has a minimal impact on handgun performance. The speaker emphasizes that training and fundamental shooting skills are far more critical factors than barrel length in determining effectiveness in a defensive scenario.

Is the Apex Tactical trigger necessary for the Smith & Wesson M&P?

The speaker finds the OEM trigger on the M&P line to be surprisingly good, with a positive break and reset. While they use an Apex trigger for consistency with other M&P models, they suggest it may not be necessary for many users, as the stock trigger performs well.

How does the 5-inch M&P conceal compared to the 4.25-inch model?

The 5-inch M&P actually conceals slightly better than the 4.25-inch model. This is due to more slide material extending below the belt line, which, according to basic physics, can aid in concealment by distributing the firearm's profile more effectively.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Concrete Cowboy

View all →